[ Copy this | Start New | Full Size ]

Login:
Password:
New messages · Members · Forum rules · Search · RSS · Profile · Logout
  • Page 1 of 7
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 6
  • 7
  • »
Forum moderator: TheWatcher, Menace, I_Guy, Aristotle  
Forum » Knowledge » Religious/Philosophical Debate » Religion Is Plague
Religion Is Plague
Menace Date: Saturday, 18/Oct/08, 2:24 PM | Message # 1

Heads
Posts: 6764
Reputation: 0
Offline
Just when we thought that religion, like smallpox, had been conquered and locked away safely in a vault, it has been released by fundamentalist terrorists of all kinds, and in new virulent forms, once again threatens the well-being of the world. I used to think that the major problem with religious belief and conservation was the injunction in the Bible that man was to dominate the beasts. Dominate the world. I now think that while that remains a problem, and a serious one, an equally damaging proposition, increasingly evident both in America and elsewhere, is the rise and rise of fundamentalism that denies the reality of evolution.

This refusal to recognise the reality of common origins of the life forms on this perhaps unique planet, of our close relationship to not just the apes but to all mammals, and our slightly more distant relationship to other vertebrates, and ultimately to all other animals, results in an attitude, a state of mind, in which all those other life forms can be extinguished. It is an attitude not unlike that which led to ethnic cleansing in Yugoslavia. It also results in a state of mind in which human life is only a waiting period to go to heaven, so that what happens to the earth while the chosen are waiting is really of not even casual interest.

It may also result in the belief that there is ultimately nothing that humans can do to damage the earth since god is in charge as a kind of maintenance engineer. In America and increasingly in other western countries there is a return to beliefs in the chain of being. God, it was believed, had created a complete hierarchy, fixed forever. It began with god at the apex, who was represented (and 'anointed by god') on Earth by the King, then down through the aristocracy in various grades and the church hierarchy running in parallel, then through freemen and down to peasants and serfs. From there the hierarchy ran through animal species starting with the more complex and ending with animals like worms. All was fixed in place immovably.

Having largely got rid of kings as rulers though, the conservatives in the society were concerned that the rest of the hierarchy, in which they had favoured places, might also be questioned. Real democracy and relative equality might take over as a human idea. If you were near the top of the hierarchy these dangerous possibilities had to be nipped in the bud and they have been. In Australia the debate over a Republic revealed the continuation of a belief in a divinely appointed figure to lead the country. In America, lacking someone with the title of king, the President, or at least Republican presidents, have increasingly taken on all the trappings of divine rule. It has the advantage that mere mortals in the media or among the populace cannot question their activities. In other countries even more clear cut theocracies have arisen again. One of the areas in which rulers cannot be questioned is of course the environment.

A religious belief which relies on evolution not having occurred is like a religious belief that relies on the sun revolving around the earth, or on thunder and lightning being the result of gods fighting, or on Spring coming only after a virgin is sacrificed.


Menace Date: Saturday, 18/Oct/08, 2:25 PM | Message # 2

Heads
Posts: 6764
Reputation: 0
Offline
There is another point. If children are receiving such a poor education that they are taught to believe in creation and not taught evolutionary biology, then they will become the kind of poorly educated adults who don't understand what is happening to the world around them. There isn't time now for the kind of fundamentalism that produces mass ill education. Nor is there time for the kind of media that sends uninformed junior reporters out on 'mother nature' stories, or which treats all animal stories as jokes. The public in general receives its adult education from the media, and it is being very poorly served. People can't vote or make life decisions without full information and understanding about environmental effects.

Fundamentalist religion also brings with it a feeling that with everything created 6000 years ago it is no big deal if some or even all are lost. A sense of the immense time that has taken to evolve both individual species and their ecological communities must surely make you pause before wantonly destroying something that is literally irreplaceable.

Furthermore if there is no time depth to the ecology of the Earth, if what we see now is what was created 6000 years ago, then there is nothing that can be learnt from past extinction events like the massive losses of species in Pleistocene times, the loss of the dinosaurs, the loss of the giant mammals. To the people who have 'museums' in which humans and dinosaurs coexist, and who interpret the history of the Grand Canyon in a biblical time scale, there were no extinction events (except of course the flood that led to Noah's Ark, perhaps one of the silliest of all the silly biblical beliefs about the history of the environment), no climatic changes. Not only can these people learn nothing from the past, they cannot therefore imagine a different future.

Finally understanding an ecosystem and the way it works involves a state of mind which can see the interconnections between things and knows that in the time since life was established on Earth there is no beginning and end to ecosystems. Nor do they have prime movers or first causes - a natural ecosystem is a self-sustaining system. Recognising that this is the way the world works would be difficult for those who believe that there is a supreme being who set everything in motion and keeps it in motion, and can be asked to set aside reality to suit the needs of a particular human individual.

In the religious mind humans in general have been set above the animal world by god as a totally separate creation. The attitude would be I guess that we could lose the whole of the natural world and it wouldn't matter, all that matters is that there would remain a bunch of humans (the ones with the correct religious beliefs obviously) on the ball of rock serving god and waiting for heaven. Environmental actions might be taken by religious people, but they would be taken from a sense of duty rather in the way that one might serve on a soup kitchen.

A country in which religious beliefs teach humans that they have no kinship with other animals, no linkages with the rest of the natural world through evolution and ecology, is also dysfunctional. Conservation of the environment has to be the result of people feeling that kinship with the world they evolved into, not one in which a few species (the deserving ones) are saved in zoos and the rest of the ecosystem destroyed. Such a strategy may work in the short term, just as putting people in workhouses works in the short term, but we urgently need approaches for both society and the environment that work in the long term. Religion is preventing the development of such approaches, not because of the belief that humans have dominion over the natural world, as important as that fallacy is, but because of the belief that humans are separate from the natural world. Religious beliefs in this area align with the ideology of economic rationalism, both blind faiths need to be left behind, and quickly


Lord_Meth Date: Saturday, 18/Oct/08, 8:15 PM | Message # 3

Heads
Posts: 6627
Reputation: 1
Offline
wow......................
prepare for a religous battle from Menace and Pensmoke


Sick With It
Menace Date: Saturday, 18/Oct/08, 8:26 PM | Message # 4

Heads
Posts: 6764
Reputation: 0
Offline
Quote (Pensmoke)
Hmm. Cant help but think I sparked this recent posting of 2 new anti-religion threads. I cannot expect someone as yourself to understand why I believe what I believe. What I believe has nothing to do with conspiracy theories or revolutionist propaganda. It has little to do with narrow minded stereotypes of what people think a Christian is. It has to do with the fact that I would almost certainly be shot dead or in jail now if not for God. I am from Memphis and cats don't care about the life of the next man. Its about the hustle and getting over there. What you and people like yourself who put Christians in a little box and label them need to understand is this: God has undeniably confirmed things in my life in DIRECT response to acting in obedience to specific Biblical promises/principles. There is nothing esoteric or trendy about my Faith. It's not the latest revolutionary cause for the young cats to jump on the bandwagon of so they can seem like they are "up on things". What I believe works for me, and has been proven to me in my OWN EXPERIENCE time and time again. Don't knock what you don't understand. Even though listening to Richard Dawkins and/or some other cats with an anti-God agenda makes you THINK you understand. Don't knock what you never tried bruh, that's all.

in fact if u could check my work u will see that i study abrahamic religions check all my threads in the political section on religion to understand me ive studied the bible the koran and the torah and i am a born muslim and i was a devoted one too but studyin the koran made me doubt the institution called religion not the religious people whit the rise of jihadism zionism im am more pushed to show the flaws of religion and what religion makes the people do the world now days as well as in the past is still in religious turmoil they are many people that are FUNDAMENTALISTS and our children are denied their education because religion i dont know why u replied if u dont see yourself as a FUNDAMENTALIST


Menace Date: Saturday, 18/Oct/08, 8:32 PM | Message # 5

Heads
Posts: 6764
Reputation: 0
Offline
and no i didnt post this because of u i usually post things regardin untaught history , politics and religious things on this site and im not talkin here about SPIRITUALITY and your connection whit God im talkin about religion if u want to put religion over god is your choice but my connection whit god is tru a SPIRITUAL bond and inside my own mind and soul so dont trip is nothing personal

laPennello Date: Saturday, 18/Oct/08, 9:06 PM | Message # 6

Watchers
I WANT IN ON THE HEATED RELIGIOUS DISCUSSION!
first off.. who is pensmoke? Menace posts knowledge in every thread he responds to. It's not like you've awakened the beast. so chill back, dude.

I don't believe in a "higher power" ex. God.
I believe in the quantum physical point of view on the situation of our lives. the laws of attraction, etc. don't get me wrong. I'm not a narrow minded, one way, "my way is the right way" type of dude. I grew up a catholic.
i've read and studied the bible. but I believe there is no greater power than what we our, ourselves. I believe we our own God(s). that we are simply, consciousness. Nothing more, nothing less. what we live and experience is a holographic view that our brains put together from the signals that we receive. I believe we are in complete control of our lives. we create what lies ahead.
I can go more in depth. but I'm on my phone. hit me with a response dude.

laPennello Date: Saturday, 18/Oct/08, 9:57 PM | Message # 7

Watchers
I meant no disrespect as well. and like you said. I was just voicing my opinion

You may be new to the website? we have in depth discussions like this a lot. So, welcome smile

I believe also that our experiences mold us to believe what we do. I said before that I grew up Catholic. I've read and studied scripture. I'm currently focusing on the Quaran. I have an open mind and would like to hear more of what you believe.
that is all I meant biggrin

Lord_Meth Date: Saturday, 18/Oct/08, 10:32 PM | Message # 8

Heads
Posts: 6627
Reputation: 1
Offline
dont worry Smoke that'll happen alot here LMAO u'll get used to it

Sick With It
laPennello Date: Sunday, 19/Oct/08, 0:00 AM | Message # 9

Watchers
Nah, don't get me wrong dude. I do not oppose any religion. As I said, I am extremely open minded and give everyone's opinion value. (except for lil wayne dick riders) I do not believe in God, but still use religion as a guideline and basis throughout my life. I see it as more of a way to set morals, to keep order. I think religion was organized to put those who wonder "what happens next?'" in a comfort zone
EmSeeD Date: Sunday, 19/Oct/08, 4:26 PM | Message # 10

Heads
Posts: 11464
Reputation: 8
Offline
like i said before, its the people who use religion as an excuse for they're own evil agenda. but than again religion is a man made thing, religion has very little to do with God, religion is just following rituals, etc.

http://chirbit.com/emseed
http://youtube.com/siwooot
eboyd Date: Sunday, 19/Oct/08, 5:06 PM | Message # 11

Heads
Posts: 13145
Reputation: 2
Offline
Quote (EmSeed)
like i said before, its the people who use religion as an excuse for they're own evil agenda. but than again religion is a man made thing, religion has very little to do with God, religion is just following rituals, etc.

whether you believe in an actually entity called "God" or, like me, don't, this is probably the most valid post in this whole thread.


my new theme song



erikboyd60@hotmail.com

"True poetry can communicate before it is understood"

-T.S. Eliot

battle record:

7-0-0

ThugzHill Date: Saturday, 08/Nov/08, 9:25 AM | Message # 12

Rappers
Posts: 59
Reputation: 0
Offline
i wanted to comm something but no,i don't want to go there.......

shall not fear no man but god, for i walk thru the valley of death.
EmSeeD Date: Saturday, 08/Nov/08, 3:16 PM | Message # 13

Heads
Posts: 11464
Reputation: 8
Offline
religion is the easiest way to control people and get them to do illogical things. religion is dangerous esp fundamentalism. They want to stick to stupid things just because they think its what's in the bible. Like euthinasia, there are times when euthinasia is the best thing, but these catholics and evangelicals wouldn't support it because they think its unbiblical. People also use religion as an excuse to control people just so it will benefit themselves eg. Evangelical preachers who use christianity to make money and gain themselves power, presidents and other world leaders who want to make war for their own countries profit, even KKK have turned their racists beliefs into an actual religion, just so next generations will find it harder to question the beliefs and actions

http://chirbit.com/emseed
http://youtube.com/siwooot
Deadly-Sin Date: Sunday, 09/Nov/08, 4:44 AM | Message # 14

Removed
Quote (EmSeed)
religion is the easiest way to control people and get them to do illogical things. religion is dangerous esp fundamentalism. They want to stick to stupid things just because they think its what's in the bible. Like euthinasia, there are times when euthinasia is the best thing, but these catholics and evangelicals wouldn't support it because they think its unbiblical. People also use religion as an excuse to control people just so it will benefit themselves eg. Evangelical preachers who use christianity to make money and gain themselves power, presidents and other world leaders who want to make war for their own countries profit, even KKK have turned their racists beliefs into an actual religion, just so next generations will find it harder to question the beliefs and actions

^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^

FACT!

EmSeeD Date: Sunday, 09/Nov/08, 1:39 PM | Message # 15

Heads
Posts: 11464
Reputation: 8
Offline
and im a person who used to be a member of a fundalmenatlist televangelist church, that church i used to go to is now turning into a cult, they want to now build their own walled city. It really makes me sad coz its these big flashy fake churches that have so many (mainly young) members but they don't realise churches like that are the ones that are full of shit.

http://chirbit.com/emseed
http://youtube.com/siwooot
Forum » Knowledge » Religious/Philosophical Debate » Religion Is Plague
  • Page 1 of 7
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 6
  • 7
  • »
Search: