[ Copy this | Start New | Full Size ]

Login:
Password:
New messages · Members · Forum rules · Search · RSS · Profile · Logout
Forum moderator: I_Guy, s0dr2, El_Matador  
Forum » Knowledge » Philosophy/Science » Purpose For Existence?
Purpose For Existence?
Menace Date: Saturday, 15/Aug/09, 7:57 AM | Message # 31

Heads
Posts: 6764
Reputation: 0
Offline
exactly I_guy points well stated and i do not advocate an ideal society the problem that we are facing today is that we created a kind of synthetic environment that is killing ourselves and our natural environment many people don't understand this but we are facing a huge disaster if we continue like this we need to establish a different kind of social environment a different kind of institutional structures that are based on solidarity , mutual aid , sympathy and such and I'm not transcending into the realm of Utopia at this point at all as many people think we need to change our economic life in order to change our social life we need a system in which people are not taken from their organic units and put into synthetic institutional structures we need to make the organic units the live motion of the world the only thing that decides where the world goes because that will bring other human values to light human values that are suppressed in the current institutional structure of our society.

Quote (I_Guy)
^^^These ideas start getting into Friedrich Nietzsche's "Ubermensch."

LOL in fact I'm a big fan of Nietzsche and that's where my tradition that of libertarian socialist or anarchist tradition always tried to reach to that is one of our ultimate goals oh and I'm currently reading Beyond Good And Evil by Nietzsche


I_Guy Date: Wednesday, 16/Dec/09, 9:52 AM | Message # 32

Heads
Posts: 1792
Reputation: 1
Offline
Life is absurd.

We all know that each of our end is near; the question is do we accept the end of our living existence, or do we accept our existence as dead men...
YANHAP1 Date: Wednesday, 16/Dec/09, 12:00 PM | Message # 33

DJs
Posts: 337
Reputation: 0
Offline
Quote (I_Guy)
Life is absurd.

:D

I would offer that we are a byproduct of our universes evolution that has allowed it, or at least part of it, to examine itself.

Wether there is purpose to that and to what ends remains unclear but possible.


who killed bambi?

eboyd Date: Wednesday, 16/Dec/09, 1:31 PM | Message # 34

Heads
Posts: 13145
Reputation: 2
Offline
Quote (YANHAP1)
I would offer that we are a byproduct of our universes evolution that has allowed it, or at least part of it, to examine itself.

Wether there is purpose to that and to what ends remains unclear but possible.

"The unexamined life is not worth living."

-Socrates


my new theme song



erikboyd60@hotmail.com

"True poetry can communicate before it is understood"

-T.S. Eliot

battle record:

7-0-0

YANHAP1 Date: Wednesday, 16/Dec/09, 2:32 PM | Message # 35

DJs
Posts: 337
Reputation: 0
Offline
Quote (eboyd)
"The unexamined life is not worth living."
-Socrates

"Fuck yo couch!"

-R.James


who killed bambi?

J-Breakz Date: Wednesday, 16/Dec/09, 4:44 PM | Message # 36

Heads
Posts: 2162
Reputation: 0
Offline
Quote (eboyd)
"The unexamined life is not worth living."

-Socrates


I never really understood that. I'd say ignorance is bliss in response to that. lol


livin life like some cheesy movie
Menace Date: Wednesday, 16/Dec/09, 5:46 PM | Message # 37

Heads
Posts: 6764
Reputation: 0
Offline
in the capitalist case greed is the purpose of existence is neither love nor other crazy ideas

J-Breakz Date: Wednesday, 16/Dec/09, 6:46 PM | Message # 38

Heads
Posts: 2162
Reputation: 0
Offline
Quote (Menace)
in the capitalist case greed is the purpose of existence is neither love nor other crazy ideas

greed or reward is incentive for people to work hard. I wouldn't say it's purpose of existence. I believe purpose of existence is to fuck and spread your gene pool and people just try to over-analyze shit.


livin life like some cheesy movie

Message edited by J-Breakz - Wednesday, 16/Dec/09, 6:46 PM
I_Guy Date: Wednesday, 16/Dec/09, 7:10 PM | Message # 39

Heads
Posts: 1792
Reputation: 1
Offline
Quote (J-Breakz)

greed or reward is incentive for people to work hard.

It also turns us into mindless robots devoid of personal meaning.

Quote (J-Breakz)
I disagree, I think capitalism allows us to do what we want. If you want to own a Pen making business because you love pens so much you can and you don't have to worry about the state setting up numerous taxes and regulations to create your pen making business. There are thousands of record labels thanks to capitalism, and people are able to create music that they want to make. How is that meaningless?

Unfortunately, the Pen corporations that currently exist make it highly unlikely to be successful. Besides, not everyone can simply start up a business like that. There are far more factors involved.

Let's just say it worked and the person was successful. Sure that person may be making meaning for the self only. But what about the workers who make the pens or and work in the warehouses and assemble lines? What about their meaning? Can you really say doing the same bullshit everyday is meaningful? That's how capitalism reduces us to meaninglessness. It turns the world into an assembly line.


We all know that each of our end is near; the question is do we accept the end of our living existence, or do we accept our existence as dead men...
J-Breakz Date: Wednesday, 16/Dec/09, 7:32 PM | Message # 40

Heads
Posts: 2162
Reputation: 0
Offline
Quote (I_Guy)
It also turns us into mindless robots devoid of personal meaning.

Getting a reward for hard work does not turn you into a mindless robot haha, at least provide an explanation, jeeze.

Quote (I_Guy)
Unfortunately, the Pen corporations that currently exist make it highly unlikely to be successful. Besides, not everyone can simply start up a business like that. There are far more factors involved.

I can actually right now order some custom made pens and sell them on the street if I want to. That's what I meant. But okay, if you want to make a living off of it then you have to come up with a business plan that would be able to compete with the pen corporations.

Quote (I_Guy)
Let's just say it worked and the person was successful. Sure that person may be making meaning for the self only. But what about the workers who make the pens or and work in the warehouses and assemble lines? What about their meaning? Can you really say doing the same bullshit everyday is meaningful? That's how capitalism reduces us to meaninglessness. It turns the world into an assembly line.

Capitalism is supposed to be about doing what you want to do. Of course working in an assembly line sucks, I wouldn't know but a lot of members of my family does. But you're not stuck in that lifestyle forever, you can always get an education to better yourself and get a job in something you want to do.


livin life like some cheesy movie
I_Guy Date: Wednesday, 16/Dec/09, 8:27 PM | Message # 41

Heads
Posts: 1792
Reputation: 1
Offline
Quote (J-Breakz)
Getting a reward for hard work does not turn you into a mindless robot haha, at least provide an explanation, jeeze.

Have you ever worked a job that requires the same thing every day? You learn nothing from it and you don't give a shit about what you are doing. It is intellectual STAGNATION. Dude seriously, read up on your fucking capitalism history. Ever heard of RUR (Rossum's Universal Robots)? It was a play written by Karel Čapek in 1921. It idealized the perfect worker, guess what, A FUCKING ROBOT. It provided the first seeds of hope for corporations. It gave them a conceptualization of the perfect worker. Though it also planted seeds of doubt because many thought it was impossible to turn people completely into robots in that day and age.

Ever heard of the Hawthorne Experiments??? They were among the first to be given hope by RUR. Social scientists motivated by corporate industry tried see how far workers could be pushed into roboticism.

Ever hear of the "Efficiency Movement?" Ever hear of "Scientific Management?" Ever hear of Henry Gantt? Ever hear of the "time and motion studies?" Ever head of Frederick Winslow Taylor??? Or Taylorism??? Also motivated by corporate industry, Taylor tried to maximize the workers output and efficiency by eliminating obstacles and reduced the work load to one simple task for each worker. The workers were not to know anything about what they were doing or what they were making, -they were simply paid to WORK. Is that not roboticism? He created worker automation, many companies followed Taylorism and it was extremely successful, until the depression hit and worker strikes forced compromise. Charlie Chaplin parodied Taylorism in his film Modern Times. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2B3HGY_zLKk
Henry Gantt improved upon Taylorism. These were the giants back then.

You can clearly see that ever since the beginning the whole idea has been to turn the worker into a ROBOT. History shows it man, ever so clearly. Yet you try to deny it when I claim it?

See people with your mentality are all the same. You have this glorious image of capitalism in your mind. You only think about the benefits of capitalism from back in its heyday, and you erroneously overlook the difference between what it once was, and what it has become.

The 19th century was the "rugged individualism" era of capitalism. It was capitalism at it's best (aside from the unavoidable corruption). The first half of the 20th century was a transitional faze and all was still pretty good. The second half of the 20th century comes along and all goes to shit. This becomes the era of corporatism, and it is COMPLETELY different than the fantasy you have attached to. You're simply naive. Wake up.

Quote (J-Breakz)
Capitalism is supposed to be about doing what you want to do.

That is fucking impossible.

Quote (J-Breakz)
you can always get an education to better yourself and get a job in something you want to do.

But there is always someone in that lousy position. I'm looking at it as a whole, not looking at it for single individuals.


We all know that each of our end is near; the question is do we accept the end of our living existence, or do we accept our existence as dead men...
J-Breakz Date: Wednesday, 16/Dec/09, 8:55 PM | Message # 42

Heads
Posts: 2162
Reputation: 0
Offline
Quote (I_Guy)
Have you ever worked a job that requires the same thing every day? You learn nothing from it and you don't give a shit about what you are doing. It is intellectual STAGNATION. Dude seriously, read up on your fucking capitalism history. Ever heard of RUR (Rossum's Universal Robots)? It was a play written by Karel Čapek in 1921. It idealized the perfect worker, i.e. A FUCKING ROBOT. It provided the first seeds of hope for corporations. It gave them a conceptualization of the perfect worker. Though it also planted seeds of doubt because many thought it was possible to turn people completely into robots.

Yes I have, and you're right, you don't learn much from it. But what's stopping you from learning something or reading a book on your free time? Many people do it. In low level jobs like making products on an assembly line the perfect worker is a robot. That's why most products we buy today are produced by machines. In fact, machines replacing human workers forces them to educate themselves to get better jobs like managing the machines and such. That in itself raises the standard of living. Now products can be manufactured in a much more efficient manner and a percentage of the population is even more educated.

Quote (I_Guy)
But there is always someone in that lousy position. I'm looking at it as a whole, not looking at it for single individuals.

Yeah have you ever lived in an area where half of the population are unemployed and most of the people who are employed just work in factories? I have for a short while with my family, in a place called Muskegon, Michigan. This is just from who I met but from my observations ALL the people who were unemployed or worked in factories spent the majority of their time doing drugs or drinking. There's nothing wrong with that, atleast not in my opinion, but you can't expect someone to have a better job (or atleast even have a job) when you're spending most of your time just coppin a buzz.

Quote (I_Guy)
That is fucking impossible.

Okay look at Jay Z. Nas. Rakim. Kid Cudi. Dr. Dre. Look at people owning businesses and trying to make a name for themselves. Look at musicians who get regular play at venues. Or college students who get to major in what they wanna learn about.

Quote (I_Guy)
See people with your mentality are all the same. You have this glorious image of capitalism in your mind. You only think about the benefits of capitalism from back in its heyday, and you erroneously overlook the difference between what it once was, and what it has become.
You seem to overlook the evidence that shows when government regulates the market the economy goes down but when the government drops control of the market then the economy improves.


livin life like some cheesy movie

Message edited by J-Breakz - Wednesday, 16/Dec/09, 8:57 PM
I_Guy Date: Wednesday, 16/Dec/09, 10:50 PM | Message # 43

Heads
Posts: 1792
Reputation: 1
Offline
Quote (J-Breakz)
But what's stopping you from learning something or reading a book on your free time? Many people do it.

That doesn't do shit if you cannot exercise that knowledge. Exercising knowledge = retainment. How can anyone possibly retain the little knowledge they gain from a couple of hours of reading a day if they have to throw away 8 hours a day (maybe more) to mindless work? You lose the information quickly if you don't interact with others and share knowledge frequently. Besides who the fuck has time to read when you have an 8+ hour shift, kids to pick up from school, kids to feed, shopping to do, laundry to do, sleep to get, on and on? What an hour or two a day at the very most? It's bullshit, you're just making bitch ass excuses for a fucked up degrading system.

Quote (J-Breakz)
Okay look at Jay Z. Nas. Rakim. Kid Cudi. Dr. Dre. Look at people owning businesses and trying to make a name for themselves. Look at musicians who get regular play at venues. Or college students who get to major in what they wanna learn about.

No shit, someone will always come out on top with something or another no matter what the circumstances are. That has nothing to do with capitalism. And it certainly has nothing to do with capitalism creating freedom.

But all in all I'm not for a monetary system to begin with. Capitalism is all about money so I attack it the most and first.

How are you so blind? You realize capitalism is a forever expanding enterprise and at some point it will reach a limit, rather it is population limit, environment limit, or whatever. That is why it is ridiculous to support capitalism, it's a dead end economy. It can't go on forever. So instead of all this fucking waste and excess, we should be advocating an economy that focuses on sustaining and preservation. It's completely absurd that people fully support capitalism. You need to look a little more into psychology, sociology, and philosophy to get a better grip on things and see the patterns. Otherwise you will remain a self-indulgent naive.


We all know that each of our end is near; the question is do we accept the end of our living existence, or do we accept our existence as dead men...
J-Breakz Date: Wednesday, 16/Dec/09, 11:21 PM | Message # 44

Heads
Posts: 2162
Reputation: 0
Offline
Quote (I_Guy)

No shit, someone will always come out on top with something or another no matter what the circumstances are. That has nothing to do with capitalism. And it certainly has nothing to do with capitalism creating freedom.

My point is ANYBODY can be a success if they work hard and provide something different and new that the people want.

Quote (I_Guy)
But all in all I'm not for a monetary system to begin with. Capitalism is all about money so I attack it the most and first.

Well what are you for?

Quote (I_Guy)
How are you so blind? You realize capitalism is a forever expanding enterprise and at some point it will reach a limit, rather it is population limit, environment limit, or whatever. That is why it is ridiculous to support capitalism, it's a dead end economy. It can't go on forever. So instead of all this fucking waste and excess, we should be advocating an economy that focuses on sustaining and preservation. It's completely absurd that people fully support capitalism. You need to look a little more into psychology, sociology, and philosophy to get a better grip on things and see the patterns. Otherwise you will remain a self-indulgent naive.
First of all, cut the whole "How are you so blind?" and other condescending crap. You're lucky people take you seriously even when you talk like that to them. If you want people to listen to you then start trying to be respectful. Damn, I try being respectful, I know there are times where I come off as a prick but that's just how I am. For the most part I always try to treat people like my equal. But back on subject:

Have you ever studied my viewpoint before attacking it? You make all these claims yet you don't provide evidence to back it up. If you're talking about the environment then here's a link that can educate you on my view points:

http://www.suite101.com/article.cfm/libertarian/42497


livin life like some cheesy movie
I_Guy Date: Wednesday, 16/Dec/09, 11:54 PM | Message # 45

Heads
Posts: 1792
Reputation: 1
Offline
Quote (J-Breakz)
My point is ANYBODY can be a success if they work hard and provide something different and new that the people want.

Myth.

Quote (J-Breakz)
Well what are you for?

Nonmonetary.

Quote (J-Breakz)
Damn, I try being respectful, I know there are times where I come off as a prick but that's just how I am.

And that's just how I am.

Quote (J-Breakz)
Have you ever studied my viewpoint before attacking it? You make all these claims yet you don't provide evidence to back it up. If you're talking about the environment then here's a link that can educate you on my view points:

I've read plenty on that bullshit. I supported capitalism once upon a time, until I woke up. Seriously, reading articles like that is not the way to get a true understanding of this kind of shit. You have to have a wholistic understanding of life and the world to conclude what economy is best (or at least be aware of the wholistic understanding). Because a wholistic understanding provides insight into other realms of society and being. It allows you to see capitalism's pros and cons better in a much more refined and accurate view. It plugs the holes that a capitalist's or an economist's fallacious arguments create. A capitalist economist may make points in defense of capitalism but be completely contradicting himself when we look at other aspects of life that are directly affected by capitalism. Having a wholistic understanding prevents this error. That's why I say look more into sociology, psychology, and philosophy, not just fucking economy only, because economy doesn't take these other fields into account.

Capitalism was not designed by intellectual people with a plan in mind. Their was nobody planning out capitalism with the health of the planet in mind, or society, or animals, or education. NO ONE blueprinted this shit. No one took a mind full of wholistic understandings and planned this shit out. Capitalism was born out of power, greed and desperation to stay alive. It is a brute economy, as brutal as it gets. No different than the desperation in the wild and just as chaotic. That's why capitalism is called "the dog that eats itself." We act like capitalism was invented or some shit. But all we have really done is tamed it. Like a rabid angry mutt it leaps around and causes destruction all in favor of the owner only. The owner sits around and makes excuses for the destruction, placing the blame on other people or circumstances, all of which are fallacies though. People try to sit around and write articles pretending that this filthy system is sophisticated. All it is is people sitting around trying to make excuses for the useful beast that no one gave birth to. They sit around and try to justify its faults, only because the system currently benefits them in particular ways, so they issue word in its favor. They try to give it definitions and terms to make it seem well defined and well rounded. But its all being done after it has been unleashed. They're simply making shit up after the fact. It is no strategized philosophy of any intellectual premeditation. That is why it is so fucked up. It might as well be a creation of nature, not of man, because it's as brutish as nature. Survival of the most fortunate is all it is.


We all know that each of our end is near; the question is do we accept the end of our living existence, or do we accept our existence as dead men...
Forum » Knowledge » Philosophy/Science » Purpose For Existence?
Search: