[ Copy this | Start New | Full Size ]

Login:
Password:
New messages · Members · Forum rules · Search · RSS · Profile · Logout
Forum moderator: TheWatcher, Menace, I_Guy, Aristotle  
Religion: Real or Fake
I_Guy Date: Tuesday, 21/Apr/09, 1:52 AM | Message # 1

Heads
Posts: 1792
Reputation: 1
Offline
What began this thread:
http://realhiphop4ever.ucoz.com/forum/12-1890-1

Religious folks need to give up.


We all know that each of our end is near; the question is do we accept the end of our living existence, or do we accept our existence as dead men...
ill Date: Saturday, 30/May/09, 8:08 PM | Message # 391

Emcees
Posts: 2087
Reputation: 0
Offline
god is just a hypothetical

The World Is Yours
I_Guy Date: Saturday, 30/May/09, 9:22 PM | Message # 392

Heads
Posts: 1792
Reputation: 1
Offline
Quote (ill)
god is just a hypothetical

Well almost any theory is hypothetical.


We all know that each of our end is near; the question is do we accept the end of our living existence, or do we accept our existence as dead men...
s0dr2 Date: Sunday, 31/May/09, 3:59 PM | Message # 393

OGs
Posts: 2772
Reputation: 1
Offline
Quote (eboyd)
also, God's omnipresence would require him to reside in hell an even inside the devil as well. do you agree sodr?

hell is the absence of God...he didn't create it, so i guess you can say hell is the only obvious exception

2 Corinthians 6:14
...
Or what fellowship can light have with darkness?

i wish to continue this but im caught up with school cry

Added (31/May/09, 3:59 Pm)
---------------------------------------------

Quote (I_Guy)
Anyways, if god is so powerful why doesn't he just destroy the devil.

ill give you an answer, not from me:

"if your giving a lector and some one expresses a different opinion do you throw him, or clarify your point and show why he is wrong.

if God had killed satan then and there is would have only proven satan's point was correct. and maybe some one else would have taken his place
instead he used satan as part of his master plan to show how, God is correct and satan isn't.
if God destroyed everyone every time they disagree or wavered in the slightest, then everyone would only worship him out of fear and not out of love."

Quote (I_Guy)
Or reveal himself in modern times to prove to everyone that he exists so that people don't have to be skeptical.

You are correct. God should reveal Himself. And He has. Throughout the centuries through the prophets, JESUS CHRIST?!?, and each day when He is present in the Eucharist.


"Twenty years from now you will be more disappointed by the things that you didn't do than by the ones you did do. So throw off the bowlines. Sail away from the safe harbour. Catch the trade winds in your sails. Explore. Dream. Discover." - Mark Twain

Menace Date: Sunday, 31/May/09, 4:46 PM | Message # 394

Heads
Posts: 6764
Reputation: 0
Offline
Quote (sodr2)
You are correct. God should reveal Himself. And He has. Throughout the centuries through the prophets, JESUS CHRIST?!?, and each day when He is present in the Eucharist.

so a DIVINE being is presented in a piece of bread or whatever that is ??

Quote (sodr2)
if God had killed satan then and there is would have only proven satan's point was correct. and maybe some one else would have taken his place
instead he used satan as part of his master plan to show how, God is correct and satan isn't.
if God destroyed everyone every time they disagree or wavered in the slightest, then everyone would only worship him out of fear and not out of love."

but he is Divine and these plans are like the plans from Oceans Thirteen LOL it does not make sense

man Sodr2 i like your passion on this but try to get straight to the point


I_Guy Date: Sunday, 31/May/09, 8:05 PM | Message # 395

Heads
Posts: 1792
Reputation: 1
Offline
Quote (sodr2)
You are correct. God should reveal Himself. And He has. Throughout the centuries through the prophets, JESUS CHRIST?!?, and each day when He is present in the Eucharist.

I said in modern times. The Eucharist does not reveal "God" in anyway.

Quote (sodr2)
hell is the absence of God...he didn't create it, so i guess you can say hell is the only obvious exception

Who created it then?

Quote (I_Guy)
the devil in a way is more powerful than god. The devil is winning by turning only one person evil. And as it seems now, god and Satan seem to be at a pretty even pace. No one is supposed to be as powerful as god.

Quote (I_Guy)
God is supposed to be all-knowing so he should have known this from the beginning. He should have known he was going to have an angel defy him and all that bullshit. Why didn’t he stop it before it started. But wait, he is supposed to be in control of everything, so therefore he made it happen. Logically it defeats itself.

You said it is all apart of his masterplan. Well then god is responsible for all the horrors in the world.


We all know that each of our end is near; the question is do we accept the end of our living existence, or do we accept our existence as dead men...
s0dr2 Date: Monday, 01/Jun/09, 1:37 AM | Message # 396

OGs
Posts: 2772
Reputation: 1
Offline
Quote (Menace)
but he is Divine and these plans are like the plans from Oceans Thirteen LOL it does not make sense

?
how is what you're saying relating to what i said about God not destroying satan?
Quote (I_Guy)
Well then god is responsible for all the horrors in the world.

dry

You have a father and a son....the son went out and murdered someone....are you telling me that the father is responsible for his son's actions? should the father go to jail? but you're saying if the father knew of his son's actions before he was born, then the father would be guilty....(minutes of thinking later) lol, i like THIS argument....ill be humble and say i dont know...at the moment, why didn't God just halt creating in the beginning if he knew people would be suffering, but ill be looking into it and get back at it

Added (01/Jun/09, 1:19 Am)
---------------------------------------------

Quote (eboyd)
human emotions are imperfect. they directly oppose rationality. when you act upon emotions you act against your better judgment, sometimes getting lucky and doing what we define as the "right" thing (i do not believe in objective morality, therefore i put the word right in quotations). when you act upon your intellect you rationalize and act "right" to the best of your knowledge. if God ever acts upon emotions he is being imperfect. seriously though, forget about calling God perfect anyways. the human concept of perfection is an unreachable paradox. saying God has emotions is fine, just don't try to attribute perfection to him if you attribute emotions to him as well, because they are contradictory to each other just as the concept of perfection itself.

human emotions are emotions...there is nothing wrong with emotions itself...we are created in God's image after all, we were initially perfect

God (probably) does act upon emotions, but He is only doing what is RIGHT, 100% of the time, never "getting luck" as you put it, He is perfect, therefore He knows how to act rationally according to whatever....human beings however can let their emotions overpower them and act against their better judgement, but that's only because they are HUMANS with emotions. i still don't see how emotions ALONE are imperfect

for example, when Jesus was crucified, He obviously was in pain and shame, feeling sad....did He send angels to come down and save Him just because He had these emotions? no, He acted justly and permitted it to happen because it was right, in order to redeem humanity (or rather each one of us personally)

Added (01/Jun/09, 1:37 Am)
---------------------------------------------
p.s. eboyd, what kind of a god would not be perfect? an "imperfect god" is more of an oxymoron, dont you think?

seriously, if you assumed a god exists, wouldn't it be obvious that he is perfect?

and i-guy, what do you think of my answer to why didn't God destroy satan...is it satisfactory or what?


"Twenty years from now you will be more disappointed by the things that you didn't do than by the ones you did do. So throw off the bowlines. Sail away from the safe harbour. Catch the trade winds in your sails. Explore. Dream. Discover." - Mark Twain



Message edited by sodr2 - Monday, 01/Jun/09, 1:54 AM
I_Guy Date: Monday, 01/Jun/09, 3:04 AM | Message # 397

Heads
Posts: 1792
Reputation: 1
Offline
Quote (sodr2)
You have a father and a son....the son went out and murdered someone....are you telling me that the father is responsible for his son's actions? should the father go to jail? but you're saying if the father knew of his son's actions before he was born, then the father would be guilty....(minutes of thinking later) lol, i like THIS argument....ill be humble and say i dont know...at the moment, why didn't God just halt creating in the beginning if he knew people would be suffering, but ill be looking into it and get back at it

Definitly not the same. You are simplifying what's going on here. A father does not govern the reality of the son nor his capacity. God does.

Quote (sodr2)
and i-guy, what do you think of my answer to why didn't God destroy satan...is it satisfactory or what?

There's really no satisfying answer. If the devil is apart of god's "master plan" therefore god is responisble for evil.


We all know that each of our end is near; the question is do we accept the end of our living existence, or do we accept our existence as dead men...
I_Guy Date: Monday, 01/Jun/09, 3:29 AM | Message # 398

Heads
Posts: 1792
Reputation: 1
Offline
We need to get of this subject because we are getting nowhere. We all feel that we couldn't be more clear.

So explain to me this:

(A past argument) Why wasn't god more clear when explaining creation so that more people would believe. He should have known their would be justified non-believers. It's kind of unfair to expect his "creations" to believe with such a lousy source (Bible) of information.

Anyways, on to more logic:

1. Sodr, do you believe in fossils? If you do, you should be aware that there are many layers of sediment that are records of the Earth's past. Within these layers exist fossils of ancient creatures. The Earth has modern creatures and it has ancient creatures. Are you aware that there are no fossils of modern creatures in ancient layers? What does that tell you? Evolution becomes quite clear. How do you explain the absence of, let's say an African Giraffe in the ancient layers of the earth? If god created all creatures at the same time, then there would be a uniform mix of fossils from all creatures through a very thick layer in the Earth's crust.

2. How would you account for the likelihood of alien life? If you think there is no alien life, why did he create so many planets dead?

3. Why is it the intelligencia of the planet do not believe in god?

4. How do you account for Neanderthals and other ancient humanoids?

5. How do you account for the horrible diseases in the world? God's creations?

It's so funny because religion sits back with its assumption feeling justified by the Bible, meanwhile science busts its ass to find the real answers and gets no respect, if fact it gets disrespect. For what? For trying to look into the truth?


We all know that each of our end is near; the question is do we accept the end of our living existence, or do we accept our existence as dead men...
s0dr2 Date: Monday, 01/Jun/09, 2:00 PM | Message # 399

OGs
Posts: 2772
Reputation: 1
Offline
Quote (I_Guy)
Definitly not the same. You are simplifying what's going on here. A father does not govern the reality of the son nor his capacity. God does.

its called an analogy, plus i did give this father the ability to look into the future, like God
Quote (I_Guy)
There's really no satisfying answer. If the devil is apart of god's "master plan" therefore god is responisble for evil.

no satisfying answer? will you not accept any answer or what? i explained how God cannot destroy satan (see above)....and now you're telling me in reply " If the devil is apart of god's "master plan" therefore god is responisble for evil."?? that doesn't relate to what we were talking about....we're not talking about if God is responsible or not, but why He didn't destroy satan, so tell me what's wrong with the answer i gave (not my personal answer)

btw i-guy eboyd or menace didnt even get a chance to respond to my thing about emotions...its tough to tackle everyone at one time, especially sinec i got no one with me


"Twenty years from now you will be more disappointed by the things that you didn't do than by the ones you did do. So throw off the bowlines. Sail away from the safe harbour. Catch the trade winds in your sails. Explore. Dream. Discover." - Mark Twain

Menace Date: Monday, 01/Jun/09, 2:11 PM | Message # 400

Heads
Posts: 6764
Reputation: 0
Offline
because you didn't give a solid answer emotions are very complex a divine being can't have them because emotions are a primitive stage of consciousness so a divine being whit a divine consciousness to have primitive emotions is ridiculous the problems is Sodr2 you result to bible quotes and other things when the answer or some answers to this you will not find in the Bible as the Catholic Church said the bible is neither a scientific book or a psychological book instead of telling why God done that and its done that go straight to the point because you didn't reply to my argument my argument states clear emotions plus divine equals incompatible

TheWatcher Date: Monday, 01/Jun/09, 2:28 PM | Message # 401

Heads
Posts: 941
Reputation: 0
Offline
Quote (Menace)
because you didn't give a solid answer emotions are very complex a divine being can't have them because emotions are a primitive stage of consciousness so a divine being whit a divine consciousness to have primitive emotions is ridiculous the problems is Sodr2 you result to bible quotes and other things when the answer or some answers to this you will not find in the Bible as the Catholic Church said the bible is neither a scientific book or a psychological book instead of telling why God done that and its done that go straight to the point because you didn't reply to my argument my argument states clear emotions plus divine equals incompatible

I definitely see what you're getting at but god created us in his imitation, which may be why both god and men have emotions. If god can love then why can't he hate? Also, wouldn't you need emotions of some sort to even care about humans? He must be attached to us in some way as a father would be to a son. If your son behaves bad, disowns you or something like that and you do love him (we're told God loves us, humans) then you're going to be hurt and eventually mad. There's a thin line between love and hate.

FYI though I'm not a fundamentalist, I don't believe that because something is written in the Bible it HAS to be the truth. After all, there's several forms of Abrahamic testaments and we all essentially believe in the same god. I believe in god and I believe in a lot that most religions preach, anyone see the Dalai Lama interview the other day? That man is admirable, really. After all the Chinese people have done to him and his nation, he's not even mad at them. He even says that he sympathized with the Chinese Officers that gave the orders to stop the protestants back in 2008 as it will help yourself gain inner peace rather than be angry at them as it's not healthy.

Every religion preaches that more or less, peace, compassion etc. I could see why you'd want God to be like that too since a man can do that - Dalai Lama. I think though that if pushed far enough Dalai Lama AS a human being like the rest of us could break, be angry and something like that and it might be the same as God but if you regret what you've done God forgives you. Either way I believe in living a good life.

Message edited by TheWatcher - Monday, 01/Jun/09, 2:30 PM
Menace Date: Monday, 01/Jun/09, 2:35 PM | Message # 402

Heads
Posts: 6764
Reputation: 0
Offline
Quote (TheWatcher)
Dalai Lama.

well if Dalai Lama reached some high consciousness and acts the way he acts how God can he on the HIGHEST level of consciousness and acts like he acts ?? that makes no sense the portrayal of God in the bible on a psychological level is to humanly even religious people can admit that something is not right in the bible and yaal gotta admit it


I_Guy Date: Tuesday, 02/Jun/09, 0:20 AM | Message # 403

Heads
Posts: 1792
Reputation: 1
Offline
Quote (sodr2)
btw i-guy eboyd or menace didnt even get a chance to respond to my thing about emotions...its tough to tackle everyone at one time, especially sinec i got no one with me

Yes they did, several times.

Quote (sodr2)
its called an analogy

A very bad one.

Quote (sodr2)
no satisfying answer?

Because it is a paradox.

Quote (TheWatcher)
If god can love then why can't he hate?

No, because hate is associated with evil. There was no evil or hate before the forbidden fruit so how could god hate when the devil created hate.

Quote (TheWatcher)
Also, wouldn't you need emotions of some sort to even care about humans? He must be attached to us in some way as a father would be to a son.

No again, you have to realize that there are answers to things and reasons for things that exist outside of emotional motives. There are logical motives created by concludions that are made by understanding cause and effect. This type of reasoning is the ultimate source of motive, because they are objective and rational. "God" may care for his creations because perhaps there is something at stake for him, or perhaps why let go of his only masterpiece. Or even perhaps to conquer the beef he has with the devil. But because he loves us....no. (keep in mind that I'm speaking as if the bible god somehow existed, I know I'm speaking as if he does, but that's just for clarity reasions).

Quote (TheWatcher)
If your son behaves bad, disowns you or something like that and you do love him (we're told God loves us, humans) then you're going to be hurt and eventually mad. There's a thin line between love and hate.

Your comparing an unimaginable perfect being to simple humans. So every "rational" thought you make about human behavior and decision making does not apply to an all perfect being that can create a cosmos. It simply doesn't apply. If you think your god made you to understand him, you are direly mistaken. You cannot compare a creator to his creations. It's like the Greeks and Romans who made their gods just like them, vulnerable to human errors. Because they lived within their natural weak human psyche and could not leap outside of it objectively, so their gods mirrored humans. It's the same thing with the modern gods. Humans project their faults upon their gods when they creations of them, because by nature human minds are faulty. The gods are supposed to be ideally all perfect, but through the "history" of these gods they clearly contradict what their perfection is supposed to be. Why? Because they were imagined by flawed humans psyches who didn't foresee the broken logic..

Beings the bible's god is a human creation, humans apply their psychology to him because humans cannot break their own psyche. Study psychology god damnit! There is alot to understand about the brain and how it fools itself in several ways.


We all know that each of our end is near; the question is do we accept the end of our living existence, or do we accept our existence as dead men...
TheWatcher Date: Tuesday, 02/Jun/09, 9:01 AM | Message # 404

Heads
Posts: 941
Reputation: 0
Offline
Quote (I_Guy)
No, because hate is associated with evil. There was no evil or hate before the forbidden fruit so how could god hate when the devil created hate.

I'm not sure if he even hated anybody, probably not (it didn't say so in anything I've read at least) but he was mad for sure. I haven't read anywhere that the devil created anger/hate either. It seems like when he and the other angels fell from heaven he had an argument with god or something like that and so I believe they were both a bit angry.

Was it the devil that created that Apple by the way or God? God created the devil so essentially God created hate? (Assuming that the devil did do that).

Quote (I_Guy)
No again, you have to realize that there are answers to things and reasons for things that exist outside of emotional motives. There are logical motives created by concludions that are made by understanding cause and effect. This type of reasoning is the ultimate source of motive, because they are objective and rational. "God" may care for his creations because perhaps there is something at stake for him, or perhaps why let go of his only masterpiece. Or even perhaps to conquer the beef he has with the devil. But because he loves us....no. (keep in mind that I'm speaking as if the bible god somehow existed, I know I'm speaking as if he does, but that's just for clarity reasions).

Am speaking as if everything in the bible was the truth as well, I may not believe in everything in there but I believe in the basics. As for the motives, why does a father care for his son/daughter? Because he/she could potentially become rich in the future and bring him wealth? Because he finally gets someone to clean up his house? Someone he can use to do this and that? You can't break love down like that. For an example you're born loving your mother, it's not something you choose to do, it's not because you have something at stake (breastmilk?) It's just there when you're born and it happens on the mother's side too. As for the father the vast majority of them love their children as well so why can't God love his?

Quote (I_Guy)
Your comparing an unimaginable perfect being to simple humans. So every "rational" thought you make about human behavior and decision making does not apply to an all perfect being that can create a cosmos. It simply doesn't apply. If you think your god made you to understand him, you are direly mistaken. You cannot compare a creator to his creations. It's like the Greeks and Romans who made their gods just like them, vulnerable to human errors. Because they lived within their natural weak human psyche and could not leap outside of it objectively, so their gods mirrored humans. It's the same thing with the modern gods. Humans project their faults upon their gods when they creations of them, because by nature human minds are faulty. The gods are supposed to be ideally all perfect, but through the "history" of these gods they clearly contradict what their perfection is supposed to be. Why? Because they were imagined by flawed humans psyches who didn't foresee the broken logic..
Beings the bible's god is a human creation, humans apply their psychology to him because humans cannot break their own psyche. Study psychology god damnit! There is alot to understand about the brain and how it fools itself in several ways.

Tell me I_Guy, who told you that God can't be compared to humans? God himself? There's no scientific research on that, no proof. God's creations were imitations of him so it's only natural that they gain all of his traits. I don't get how I can't compare a creator to creations IF the creator intended for the creations to be just like him. Again, you were speaking as if you believed in God but still that there was any scientific proof for him not being like humans (there is none, if you're going to talk from a Christian's perspective then understand that if God hasn't stated it then how in the world do you know? I'll assume that you're not a scientist and that you haven't performed any psychological exams on any other gods so really, you have nothing what so ever to back up the "you're direly mistaken" statement.)

I_Guy Date: Tuesday, 02/Jun/09, 3:52 PM | Message # 405

Heads
Posts: 1792
Reputation: 1
Offline
Quote (TheWatcher)
Tell me I_Guy, who told you that God can't be compared to humans? God himself? There's no scientific research on that, no proof. God's creations were imitations of him so it's only natural that they gain all of his traits. I don't get how I can't compare a creator to creations IF the creator intended for the creations to be just like him. Again, you were speaking as if you believed in God but still that there was any scientific proof for him not being like humans (there is none, if you're going to talk from a Christian's perspective then understand that if God hasn't stated it then how in the world do you know? I'll assume that you're not a scientist and that you haven't performed any psychological exams on any other gods so really, you have nothing what so ever to back up the "you're direly mistaken" statement.)

Scientific proof??? There's no fucking proof for god period. So you can't bring in that argument. There's no scientific evidence that he exists in the first place. So to use an evidence argument for this is absurd.


We all know that each of our end is near; the question is do we accept the end of our living existence, or do we accept our existence as dead men...
Search: