[ Copy this | Start New | Full Size ]

Login:
Password:
New messages · Members · Forum rules · Search · RSS · Profile · Logout
Forum moderator: TheWatcher, Menace, I_Guy, Aristotle  
Religion: Real or Fake
I_Guy Date: Tuesday, 21/Apr/09, 1:52 AM | Message # 1

Heads
Posts: 1792
Reputation: 1
Offline
What began this thread:
http://realhiphop4ever.ucoz.com/forum/12-1890-1

Religious folks need to give up.


We all know that each of our end is near; the question is do we accept the end of our living existence, or do we accept our existence as dead men...
ill Date: Tuesday, 02/Jun/09, 4:02 PM | Message # 406

Emcees
Posts: 2087
Reputation: 0
Offline
Quote (sodr2)
p.s. eboyd, what kind of a god would not be perfect? an "imperfect god" is more of an oxymoron, dont you think?
seriously, if you assumed a god exists, wouldn't it be obvious that he is perfect?
and i-guy, what do you think of my answer to why didn't God destroy satan...is it satisfactory or what

ok im just throwing this out there, if god is perfect so must everything he create right? because if not he has not been perfect while making it. you can say people die is all part of gods plan, so we can still be perfect in that aspect even with diformaties but we are not perfect cos we ate from the tree


The World Is Yours


Message edited by ill - Tuesday, 02/Jun/09, 4:03 PM
Menace Date: Tuesday, 02/Jun/09, 4:12 PM | Message # 407

Heads
Posts: 6764
Reputation: 0
Offline
Quote (TheWatcher)
Tell me I_Guy, who told you that God can't be compared to humans? God himself? There's no scientific research on that, no proof. God's creations were imitations of him so it's only natural that they gain all of his traits.

we are not perfect then God's not perfect either you made my point

Quote (TheWatcher)
Was it the devil that created that Apple by the way or God? God created the devil so essentially God created hate? (Assuming that the devil did do that)

pretty much made our points LOL biggrin


eboyd Date: Tuesday, 02/Jun/09, 7:47 PM | Message # 408

Heads
Posts: 13145
Reputation: 2
Offline
I agree with Menace.

And as I stated before, the concept of perfection is a self-defeating paradox.


my new theme song



erikboyd60@hotmail.com

"True poetry can communicate before it is understood"

-T.S. Eliot

battle record:

7-0-0

eboyd Date: Tuesday, 02/Jun/09, 7:54 PM | Message # 409

Heads
Posts: 13145
Reputation: 2
Offline
Btw, "God created us in his image" = metaphor meaning: "the initial cause of the universe (God) was an energy source that created everything by splitting into matter and anti-matter and all of it came from that energy source therefore everything is one unified substance and God literally created us out of his own substance." wink

my new theme song



erikboyd60@hotmail.com

"True poetry can communicate before it is understood"

-T.S. Eliot

battle record:

7-0-0

eboyd Date: Tuesday, 02/Jun/09, 7:55 PM | Message # 410

Heads
Posts: 13145
Reputation: 2
Offline
But in reality, man created God in his image (mentally) biggrin

my new theme song



erikboyd60@hotmail.com

"True poetry can communicate before it is understood"

-T.S. Eliot

battle record:

7-0-0

s0dr2 Date: Tuesday, 02/Jun/09, 10:45 PM | Message # 411

OGs
Posts: 2772
Reputation: 1
Offline
Quote (Menace)
because you didn't give a solid answer

i gave an answer....you didn't respond to it....how about you QUOTE ME and tell me where im wrong or misunderstanding something...ill repeat my answer again (plus u say i resort to the bible, when i didn't mention any passages PLUS you're the one USING the bible describing God with emotions, so obviously i also have to use the bible to try and refute what you're saying):

Quote (sodr2)

human emotions are emotions...there is nothing wrong with emotions itself...we are created in God's image after all, we were initially perfect

God (probably) does act upon emotions, but He is only doing what is RIGHT, 100% of the time, never "getting luck" as you put it, He is perfect, therefore He knows how to act rationally according to whatever....human beings however can let their emotions overpower them and act against their better judgement, but that's only because they are HUMANS with emotions. i still don't see how emotions ALONE are imperfect

for example, when Jesus was crucified, He obviously was in pain and shame, feeling sad....did He send angels to come down and save Him just because He had these emotions? no, He acted justly and permitted it to happen because it was right, in order to redeem humanity (or rather each one of us personally)

Quote (I_Guy)

Yes they did, several times.

huh? no they didn't, not to the answer i gave above

Quote (I_Guy)
A very bad one.

no it isnt, i explained how it would work, but youre not mentioning it, but w/e

Quote (I_Guy)
Scientific proof??? There's no fucking proof for god period. So you can't bring in that argument. There's no scientific evidence that he exists in the first place. So to use an evidence argument for this is absurd.

i cant believe this....i gave you an answer a few pages ago for a question that you asked me on why the Bible God exists, but you didn't bother to respond, but moved onto other subjects like emotions...i thought we were tackling one subject at a time anyways, so why do you have to say "PERIOD" when we didn't even get to that yet? it shows your closed mindedness since we didn't even finish debating for you to look at all the facts, yet you bluntly insist that there is no proof ...i told you before to have religious conviction, you need to have a willingness to know the truth

p.s. God exists outside of the realms of science, so what kind of an idiot would use scientific tools to detect him??

ok im out to study, ill let the watcher take my place...peace

Added (02/Jun/09, 10:45 Pm)
---------------------------------------------

Quote (some guy)
According to one definition of the word evil, God created evil. Isaiah 45:7 says that God creates evil.

However according to another definition of evil, God does not create evil.

When it comes to the evil of sin, God is not the maker of golden idols. The gold that the idol is made out of is God's creation, but gold is not a sin. It's the misuse of the gold that is a sin. But the Bible makes it very clear that God does not create idols.

Sin is not God's creation. Sin is the misuse of God's creation, therefore it is man's creation, not God's.

However, when it comes to the evil of calamity and doom, God created calamity for Sodom and Gomorrah when He rained fire and brimstone down upon them, when he flooded the world in the days of Noah, and when He sent 10 plagues against Egypt. So yes, according to this definition of evil, God creates evil.



"Twenty years from now you will be more disappointed by the things that you didn't do than by the ones you did do. So throw off the bowlines. Sail away from the safe harbour. Catch the trade winds in your sails. Explore. Dream. Discover." - Mark Twain



Message edited by sodr2 - Tuesday, 02/Jun/09, 10:42 PM
EmSeeD Date: Wednesday, 03/Jun/09, 1:15 AM | Message # 412

Heads
Posts: 11464
Reputation: 8
Offline
Quote (I_Guy)
No, because hate is associated with evil. There was no evil or hate before the forbidden fruit so how could god hate when the devil created hate.

there's a righteous kind of hate,

of course a perfect God would hate evil, why would he love evil?


http://chirbit.com/emseed
http://youtube.com/siwooot
eboyd Date: Wednesday, 03/Jun/09, 1:23 AM | Message # 413

Heads
Posts: 13145
Reputation: 2
Offline
Dude, perfection is such a fickle term. Everyone can redefine it as they please. So to say God is perfect is truly useless.

my new theme song



erikboyd60@hotmail.com

"True poetry can communicate before it is understood"

-T.S. Eliot

battle record:

7-0-0

ill Date: Wednesday, 03/Jun/09, 6:06 AM | Message # 414

Emcees
Posts: 2087
Reputation: 0
Offline
but sodr what about my question lol

The World Is Yours
Menace Date: Wednesday, 03/Jun/09, 6:46 AM | Message # 415

Heads
Posts: 6764
Reputation: 0
Offline
Quote (sodr2)
uman emotions are emotions...there is nothing wrong with emotions itself...we are created in God's image after all, we were initially perfect

God (probably) does act upon emotions, but He is only doing what is RIGHT, 100% of the time, never "getting luck" as you put it, He is perfect, therefore He knows how to act rationally according to whatever....human beings however can let their emotions overpower them and act against their better judgement, but that's only because they are HUMANS with emotions. i still don't see how emotions ALONE are imperfect

for example, when Jesus was crucified, He obviously was in pain and shame, feeling sad....did He send angels to come down and save Him just because He had these emotions? no, He acted justly and permitted it to happen because it was right, in order to redeem humanity (or rather each one of us personally)

emotions are primitive forms of consciousness a supreme being whit a supreme consciousness acting on primitive instincts is ridiculous in PSYCHOLOGICAL studies we learned that emotions plus divinity equals incompatible study some psychology man


I_Guy Date: Thursday, 04/Jun/09, 0:40 AM | Message # 416

Heads
Posts: 1792
Reputation: 1
Offline
Quote (sodr2)
so why do you have to say "PERIOD" when we didn't even get to that yet? it shows your closed mindedness since we didn't even finish debating for you to look at all the facts, yet you bluntly insist that there is no proof ...i told you before to have religious conviction, you need to have a willingness to know the truth

I said there is no "SCIENTIFIC EVIDENCE," that is absolute fact. So everything you said above means nothing.

Quote (sodr2)
no it isnt, i explained how it would work, but youre not mentioning it, but w/e

Nope, it was terrible. I already said why it wouldn't work, but there's no use explaining again to a person who is incapable of understanding rational comparisons.

Quote (sodr2)
human emotions are emotions...there is nothing wrong with emotions itself...we are created in God's image after all, we were initially perfect
God (probably) does act upon emotions, but He is only doing what is RIGHT, 100% of the time, never "getting luck" as you put it, He is perfect, therefore He knows how to act rationally according to whatever....human beings however can let their emotions overpower them and act against their better judgement, but that's only because they are HUMANS with emotions. i still don't see how emotions ALONE are imperfect
for example, when Jesus was crucified, He obviously was in pain and shame, feeling sad....did He send angels to come down and save Him just because He had these emotions? no, He acted justly and permitted it to happen because it was right, in order to redeem humanity (or rather each one of us personally)

Quote (sodr2)
huh? no they didn't, not to the answer i gave above

What the fuck are they supposed to respond to????????? If you want a response be fucking clear when you want one. Construct your sentence accordingly so that people no you want a response.

Quote (sodr2)
God exists outside of the realms of science, so what kind of an idiot would use scientific tools to detect him??

Does the bible say that?

Quote (sodr2)
i cant believe this....i gave you an answer a few pages ago for a question that you asked me on why the Bible God exists, but you didn't bother to respond, but moved onto other subjects like emotions...i thought we were tackling one subject at a time

WHAT THE FUCK ARE TALKING ABOUT???????!?!?!?!?!? What qualifies as a response? I responded several times in different ways. One of the ways was explaining the emotion and psychology aspect. Those are some of my counter arguments that work to challenge the bible, in which you so strongly believe. By the way I didn't ask why the bible exists, I asked how do you know the bible is right. Big difference.


We all know that each of our end is near; the question is do we accept the end of our living existence, or do we accept our existence as dead men...
I_Guy Date: Thursday, 04/Jun/09, 0:45 AM | Message # 417

Heads
Posts: 1792
Reputation: 1
Offline
Quote (Menace)
emotions are primitive forms of consciousness a supreme being whit a supreme consciousness acting on primitive instincts is ridiculous in PSYCHOLOGICAL studies we learned that emotions plus divinity equals incompatible study some psychology man

Dude Menace, just leave it alone man, he's not going to get it. Next subject.


We all know that each of our end is near; the question is do we accept the end of our living existence, or do we accept our existence as dead men...
s0dr2 Date: Thursday, 04/Jun/09, 3:39 PM | Message # 418

OGs
Posts: 2772
Reputation: 1
Offline
Quote (I_Guy)
What the fuck are they supposed to respond to????????? If you want a response be fucking clear when you want one. Construct your sentence accordingly so that people no you want a response.

lol, calm down...i asked for a response not from you, and i got one, so you dont need to get in this saying im not clear when im not even talking to you

Quote (I_Guy)

Does the bible say that?

i dont think i need to pull passages arguing that God does not consist of matter or is not bound in time....but anyways,

John 8:58
"I tell you the truth," Jesus answered, "before Abraham was born, I am!"

Quote (I_Guy)
WHAT THE FUCK ARE TALKING ABOUT???????!?!?!?!?!?

correction: "...are YOU talking about?" Please construct your sentences accordingly to make them more clear.

Quote (I_Guy)
What qualifies as a response?

nothing complex...possibly a little quoting and counter arguing...

Quote (I_Guy)
I responded several times in different ways. One of the ways was explaining the emotion and psychology aspect.

that's where you went wrong....you label "emotion" and "psychology" as a valid response to my explanation of why the Bible God exists (ie PROPHECIES)...look what you said:

Quote (I_Guy)
The "evidence" (prophecies) you showed me are not valid because they are vulnerable to misinterpretation, and therefore any truth that there may be, is smeared by the hand of the interpreter. I don't want to go into this because this is away from psychology and will be explained when we move Epistemology and Philology.

...when really, a valid response would be you elaborating and going into "epistemology" and "philology", but you went on and posted videos of on other topics and asking other questions

Quote (I_Guy)
By the way I didn't ask why the bible exists, I asked how do you know the bible is right. Big difference.

huh? I said Bible GOD, not Bible, reread what i said, its the exactly as you asked

Added (04/Jun/09, 3:39 Pm)
---------------------------------------------

Quote (Menace)
emotions are primitive forms of consciousness a supreme being whit a supreme consciousness acting on primitive instincts is ridiculous in PSYCHOLOGICAL studies we learned that emotions plus divinity equals incompatible study some psychology man

even though you simply quoted what i said and didn't actually getting into my counter argument....im still trying to grasp this....

so why should emotions be primitive forms of consciousness/instincts when they are FROm God and we are made in God's image...? who says emotions are imperfect when God created us perfect with emotions?

or if im still being a pain asking for clarification, we can move on like i-guy mentioned....


"Twenty years from now you will be more disappointed by the things that you didn't do than by the ones you did do. So throw off the bowlines. Sail away from the safe harbour. Catch the trade winds in your sails. Explore. Dream. Discover." - Mark Twain



Message edited by sodr2 - Thursday, 04/Jun/09, 3:32 PM
Menace Date: Thursday, 04/Jun/09, 3:50 PM | Message # 419

Heads
Posts: 6764
Reputation: 0
Offline
Quote (sodr2)
so why should emotions be primitive forms of consciousness/instincts when they are FROm God and we are made in God's image...? who says emotions are imperfect when God created us perfect with emotions?

PSYCHOLOGY SAYS THAT THE SCIENCE that studies the mind the mind and conscience is what propagates behavior


I_Guy Date: Thursday, 04/Jun/09, 11:55 PM | Message # 420

Heads
Posts: 1792
Reputation: 1
Offline
Quote (sodr2)
lol, calm down...i asked for a response not from you, and i got one, so you dont need to get in this saying im not clear when im not even talking to you

You directed your statement to me, saying that the others didn't respond to you before. Therefore I can respond to that complaint.

Quote (sodr2)
correction: "...are YOU talking about?" Please construct your sentences accordingly to make them more clear.

Who gives a fuck, there's dozens of times I could have corrected your dumb mispelling ass.

Quote (sodr2)
nothing complex

Why, you can't handle it? Exactly the reason why you believe in the bible. crazy

Quote (sodr2)
when really, a valid response would be you elaborating and going into "epistemology" and "philology", but you went on and posted videos of on other topics and asking other questions

We got into psychology first so I didn't want to deviate.

Quote (sodr2)
huh? I said Bible GOD, not Bible, reread what i said, its the exactly as you asked

This is exactly what I said, notice there is absolutely no "Why" question here.
Quote (I_Guy)
So my basic question is (just to give me a place to start): How do you know the Bible's God exists?

And now the reason why I got into psychology after you showed me the prophecies that are supposed to be proof of the Bible's God existing..
Quote (I_Guy)
The psychology that I was getting into was an attempt to explain how religious folks "invent" these prophecies.

Quote (sodr2)
or if im still being a pain asking for clarification, we can move on like i-guy mentioned....

Fucking move on! There's no hope for you on this topic. How fucking typical to get into a rediculous bickering with a person like you. Distracting the debate with petty minded insignificant bullshit. Who gives a fuck about this and that specific detail, just fucking respond with your defense.

Now that we have gone back over the trail of this argument can we fucking continue?


We all know that each of our end is near; the question is do we accept the end of our living existence, or do we accept our existence as dead men...
Search: