[ Copy this | Start New | Full Size ]

Login:
Password:
New messages · Members · Forum rules · Search · RSS · Profile · Logout
Forum moderator: I_Guy, s0dr2, El_Matador  
Vegetarianism
I_Guy Date: Friday, 05/Feb/10, 4:50 PM | Message # 211

Heads
Posts: 1792
Reputation: 1
Offline
Watch the whole video or bit by bit further below (though I recommend watching the whole thing). (I just found this recently and it relates well to our convo)






And dumb ass news casters report "Crazed animal attacks trainer." Hmmm I wonder why. "All well put the wild beast down."







We all know that each of our end is near; the question is do we accept the end of our living existence, or do we accept our existence as dead men...
I_Guy Date: Friday, 05/Feb/10, 5:03 PM | Message # 212

Heads
Posts: 1792
Reputation: 1
Offline
Quote (abanks47)
The family dog was loved, and people shed tears when they died.

The family slave was sometimes loved.

Quote (abanks47)
but dont try to think for a second that slaves were treated in a humane way.

I don't think that. But this whole slavery argument is pointless. Do you remember how it got started?

Quote (abanks47)
LOL shut the fuck up, show me any proof of a ship with any type of living creatures in those conditions in those days.

I provided loads in those videos. So you shut the fuck up. What the fuck you think? We transport animals in first class air planes?

Quote (abanks47)
but most who come at me are within those standards.

How do you know?

Besides, it's not so much the consumption of meat. I understand the difficulties people face in life which makes it hard to get off meat. I am mainly criticizing the slaughter of animals for profit and criticizing any perspective that supports such acts. So it really doesn't matter whether a person eats meat or not. I don't think people are in control of themselves, so I don't see any blame, or hypocracy. As long as they are supporting the elimination of animal slaughter then it's all good. Someone may eat meat but hate eating meat and hate the slaughter-houses that produce it. That's fine as long as they are against it. They can do both because the issue is sometimes more complicated than doing one or the other.

Quote (abanks47)
its not difficult to leave your feelings on the side and to not let them get into a conversation, especially when there in regards to a choice that someone has not practiced there entire lives. that shit is for children not adults. Strong willed can control there emotions.

Let's not get into the whole free-will debate. But I disagree with you.

Quote (abanks47)
i can eat this by itself without any sides, i have and will continue to do so until my inevitable death from a car crash when im 38.

You mean death from heart disease, due to over-consumption of beef?

Quote (abanks47)
pork does not smell like feces homie.

Smell again, and think about it. No seasoning, just the stiff cooked flesh of the animal. Then get back to me.
http://answers.yahoo.com/question/index?qid=20070617162302AA7YM3l


We all know that each of our end is near; the question is do we accept the end of our living existence, or do we accept our existence as dead men...
abanks47 Date: Friday, 05/Feb/10, 5:43 PM | Message # 213

Emcees
Posts: 1466
Reputation: 0
Offline
Quote (I_Guy)
The family slave was sometimes loved.

only by the kids that were raised by "mammy". no one marched down to the fields to play with the slaves. sorry, they did with spot the golden retriever though

Quote (I_Guy)
I don't think that. But this whole slavery argument is pointless. Do you remember how it got started?

Yes i do, you were comparing that the vegetarian struggle to that of slave abolitionists. i took it the wrong way but you continued to humor me by making the argument that animals were being treated in the same ways that slaves were back in the day and in some ways yes they are in modern times, but back than i dont think animals were treated as bad or worse than slaves. with the exception of pests and rodents

Also look at alcatraz's sig. that pretty much sums it up

Quote (I_Guy)
I provided loads in those videos. So you shut the fuck up. What the fuck you think? We transport animals in first class air planes?

Haha, your feelings are showing, i never said that but animals are not shackled in the dark for days with little to no food. actually in most cases i would imagine it to be pretty stupid to ship live livestock all at once. id imagine they'd be butchered overseas than shipped out. other cases a male and female would be shipped for breeding purposes. never a full load like the middle passage ships. your move

Quote (I_Guy)
How do you know?

Besides, it's not so much the consumption of meat. I understand the difficulties people face in life which makes it hard to get off meat. I am mainly criticizing the slaughter of animals for profit and criticizing any perspective that supports such acts. So it really doesn't matter whether a person eats meat or not. I don't think people are in control of themselves, so I don't see any blame, or hypocracy. As long as they are supporting the elimination of animal slaughter then it's all good. Someone may eat meat but hate eating meat and hate the slaughter-houses that produce it. That's fine as long as they are against it. They can do both because the issue is sometimes more complicated than doing one or the other.


I am in support of unneccessary slaughter but not the slaughter of animals that end up on my plate. if an animal is killed for sport, yeah i think that is cruel and should stop, but if there going to eat it, do your thing.

Also i know because random strangers dont walk up to me telling me to stop eating, many cases these are friends or acquaintances whom i know personally and they tell me they just picked up on this life altering experience. its real hot in SF. youd fit right in

Quote (I_Guy)
Let's not get into the whole free-will debate. But I disagree with you.

LOL, you cant control your emotions. do you just break out into tears at random?

Quote (I_Guy)

You mean death from heart disease, due to over-consumption of beef?

No i believe i was quite clear that i'd die in a car crash. remember when i typed it, than you quoted it? what comments have i made that lead you to believe that i over-consume meat? i'm actually quite skinny, freakishly skinny in fact.

Quote (I_Guy)
Smell again, and think about it. No seasoning, just the stiff cooked flesh of the animal. Then get back to me.
http://answers.yahoo.com/question/index?qid=20070617162302AA7YM3l

I've had it. the only pork that smells like that is chitlins, and with reason.


A WELL DRESSED SKELETON SLOWLY CUTS YOUR THROAT.

"I Have No Fear Whatsoever of Anybody or Anything" -Malcolm X

“those who consider themselves the most adamant adherents of “real” hip-hop can also be the least knowledgeable.” –Adilifu Nama; an excert from his perception of Nas’s “Genesis”

I_Guy Date: Friday, 05/Feb/10, 5:55 PM | Message # 214

Heads
Posts: 1792
Reputation: 1
Offline
Quote (abanks47)
but back than i dont think animals were treated as bad or worse than slaves. with the exception of pests and rodents

WTF, how can you think that? If they treated HUMAN BEINGS badly back then, then of course they would have no problem treating animals badly back then.

You can think whatever you like, but that doesn't mean anything regarding the truth.

Quote (abanks47)
Haha, your feelings are showing, i never said that but animals are not shackled in the dark for days with little to no food. actually in most cases i would imagine it to be pretty stupid to ship live livestock all at once. id imagine they'd be butchered overseas than shipped out. other cases a male and female would be shipped for breeding purposes. never a full load like the middle passage ships. your move

Watch those fucking videos god damn it, before you start blabbering "what you think."

Quote (abanks47)
other cases a male and female would be shipped for breeding purposes. never a full load like the middle passage ships. your move

How else were they supposed to ship them? One by one in private sail boats? And yes, animals are shipped over seas just like slaves were. Of course better technology has allowed for more efficient transport though.

Quote (abanks47)
I am in support of unneccessary slaughter but not the slaughter of animals that end up on my plate. if an animal is killed for sport, yeah i think that is cruel and should stop, but if there going to eat it, do your thing.

Not to long ago you were laughing at speciesism.

Quote (abanks47)
Also i know because random strangers dont walk up to me telling me to stop eating, many cases these are friends or acquaintances whom i know personally and they tell me they just picked up on this life altering experience. its real hot in SF. youd fit right in

Let's hope they are sufficiently philosophically aware, and not doing it as a part of a fad.

Quote (abanks47)
LOL, you cant control your emotions. do you just break out into tears at random?

Of course not. But under some circumstances some people do. I have before. I can see you are nowhere near aware enough of human nature. But who knows, that's okay, this is a tangent.

Quote (abanks47)
what comments have i made that lead you to believe that i over-consume meat?

This...
Quote (abanks47)
no joke, my favorite food is burnt bland steak.

I don't know about you, but I consume my favorite food a lot. I do so because it's my favorite.


We all know that each of our end is near; the question is do we accept the end of our living existence, or do we accept our existence as dead men...
abanks47 Date: Friday, 05/Feb/10, 6:37 PM | Message # 215

Emcees
Posts: 1466
Reputation: 0
Offline
Quote (I_Guy)
WTF, how can you think that? If they treated HUMAN BEINGS badly back then, then of course they would have no problem treating animals badly back then.

You can think whatever you like, but that doesn't mean anything regarding the truth.


same goes for you. simply stating your cause doesnt make it relevant, important or even close to actual struggles fought throughout history. i've said in many ways why i think animals could have been treated better than slaves. i said it. do you really want me to explain it again. dry your eyes.
Quote (I_Guy)

Watch those fucking videos god damn it, before you start blabbering "what you think.

lol, you're feelings are a bubbling pot of tears right now. i will watch them when i get home, not really safe to watch goats being smacked in the head with a hammer. (i-guy cries when he reads that comment)
Quote (I_Guy)
How else were they supposed to ship them? One by one in private sail boats? And yes, animals are shipped over seas just like slaves were. Of course better technology has allowed for more efficient transport.

Air or ship but like i said i dont think they shipped them like they did slaves. and in the same quantities. they slaughter the animals before sending overseas so cost of upkeep is lowered. i_guy your silly, sail boats? thats really dumb.

Quote (I_Guy)
Not to long ago you were laughing at speciesism.

Wow, i worded that wrong and do not believe that i meant
"I am NOT in support of unneccessary slaughter "
i dont hate any other species LOL, i suh am not a specieist
Quote (I_Guy)
Let's hope they are sufficiently philosophically aware, and not doing it as a part of a fad.

I hope so as well

Quote (I_Guy)
Of course not. But under some circumstances some people do. I have before. I can see you are nowhere near aware enough of human nature. But who knows, that's okay, this is a tangent.

of course you can see that. i am a transparent shell of a man and my core can be cut by a vegetarian like tender steak with a samurai sword. i aint no cold blooded monster, i love too but i can control my emotions. i dont let them get the best of me (in most cases). i dont shed tears because it does no good. what does breaking down over a situation and losing your wits and instincts going to help? nothing.

Quote (I_Guy)
I don't know about you, but I consume my favorite food a lot. I do so because it's my favorite.

Well i dont, i know portion control and very rarely do i gorge on any food, with the exception of pizza. dont know why but do for some strange reason. steak is a rare tasty treat that is not consumed regularly

Apologies to you I_guy if any of my off-handed comments insulted you. its all in fun but i do still stand by my actual statements


A WELL DRESSED SKELETON SLOWLY CUTS YOUR THROAT.

"I Have No Fear Whatsoever of Anybody or Anything" -Malcolm X

“those who consider themselves the most adamant adherents of “real” hip-hop can also be the least knowledgeable.” –Adilifu Nama; an excert from his perception of Nas’s “Genesis”

I_Guy Date: Saturday, 06/Feb/10, 1:32 AM | Message # 216

Heads
Posts: 1792
Reputation: 1
Offline
Quote (abanks47)
same goes for you. simply stating your cause doesnt make it relevant, important or even close to actual struggles fought throughout history. i've said in many ways why i think animals could have been treated better than slaves. i said it. do you really want me to explain it again. dry your eyes.

You seem to mistake assumptions for evidence and argument. Dry my eyes? You got the wrong idea here. I'm don't feel motivated to waste anymore time with you. Your not being as reasonable as you need to be for a debate like this . You don't seem to be aware of the foundations of argument method.

Quote (abanks47)
lol, you're feelings are a bubbling pot of tears right now. i will watch them when i get home, not really safe to watch goats being smacked in the head with a hammer. (i-guy cries when he reads that comment)

Wow man, you are making outlandish judgements. Pretty childish of you. You got the wrong idea of me. If you only knew for real.

Quote (abanks47)
but i can control my emotions. i dont let them get the best of me (in most cases). i dont shed tears because it does no good. what does breaking down over a situation and losing your wits and instincts going to help? nothing.

That's what you think. You'll get older and realize that it's not so easy under stress. You think your a big strong man don't ya'. B)


We all know that each of our end is near; the question is do we accept the end of our living existence, or do we accept our existence as dead men...
abanks47 Date: Saturday, 06/Feb/10, 3:08 AM | Message # 217

Emcees
Posts: 1466
Reputation: 0
Offline
Quote (I_Guy)
You seem to mistake assumptions for evidence and argument. Dry my eyes? You got the wrong idea here. I'm not going to waste anymore time with you. Your not reasonable. Your not aware of the foundations of argument.

WTF you talking about? you said that vegetarians fight is similar to that of slave abolitionists. you have not IN ANY CAPACITY proven that. granted we got off topic but i AM A REASONABLE MAN. i will move on and hear what your basis is for that claim. if you're backing off because you cant prove that than that's fine. if your backing off because i wont change my opinion well im sorry but i happen to be very strong willed when it comes to comparisons to the freedom of my people (if you give me proof of this by all means i will consider agreeing). just as you are passionate about vegetarians i am with my black heritage. you need to prove this otherwise stop making the claim and shut the fuck up.

Quote (I_Guy)
Wow man, you are making outlandish judgements. Pretty childish of you. You got the wrong idea of me. If you only knew, ha ha.

Is that really an outlandish judgment to you? I hate to see what would happen if you were accused of murder. in any case i apologize if i offended you deary.

Quote (I_Guy)
That's what you think. You'll get older and realize that it's not so easy under stress. You think your a big strong man don't ya'. B)

Yo just as i dont know you, you dont know me nor the shit i've seen, done or lived through. I'm an adult. peep what you just said and i think you will see it was wrong and you have no grounds for saying it. i grew up real fast because of the life experiences i lived through at a very early age. i think i am a strong emotional man yes, because like i said getting super emotional over something you dont have control over is to me pointless. i show emotion when it is beneficial but if it serves no point why do it? if humans can stop eating meat why can they not rid themselves of emotion as well? im not saying i dont get sad or depressed but it will not control me and never will affect those around me so go eat some twigs


A WELL DRESSED SKELETON SLOWLY CUTS YOUR THROAT.

"I Have No Fear Whatsoever of Anybody or Anything" -Malcolm X

“those who consider themselves the most adamant adherents of “real” hip-hop can also be the least knowledgeable.” –Adilifu Nama; an excert from his perception of Nas’s “Genesis”

eboyd Date: Saturday, 06/Feb/10, 3:46 AM | Message # 218

Heads
Posts: 13145
Reputation: 2
Offline
Abanks, Stalin's death toll trumps Hitler's by quite a bit. Do we say that "what Hitler did doesn't compare to what Stalin did" and use that statement to justify what Hitler did? No. While the statement is technically true, that still doesn't change that what Hitler did was one of the most terrible atrocities in human history. Genocide is genocide, no matter what the scale or degree. Same goes for the situation you describe. Slavery is slavery, regardless of the scale or degree. This goes for any atrocity (of which what we do to animals covers quite a few).

Here's my question to you as both a meat eater and a fellow human seeking to live by the best morals possible: would you agree that if we could sufficiently replace meat (in price, taste, nutritional value, etc.), being as -- I would assume -- we can both agree that humans are in no way more valuable than animals, that it would be morally correct for us to oblige to discontinue the consumption of meat?


my new theme song



erikboyd60@hotmail.com

"True poetry can communicate before it is understood"

-T.S. Eliot

battle record:

7-0-0

I_Guy Date: Saturday, 06/Feb/10, 4:16 AM | Message # 219

Heads
Posts: 1792
Reputation: 1
Offline
Quote (abanks47)
you have not IN ANY CAPACITY proven that

WHAT THE FUCK IS PROOF TO YOU??????????? Do you realize that neither of us can PROVE our claim? That's why you are not reasonable and don't understand the foundations of logical arguments. All I can do is provide evidence, and if your dense ass can't put it together then there is nothing I can do about it.

ANIMAL TREATMENT IS LIKE SLAVE TREATMENT BECAUSE:
P1: Humans dominate other animals just like slave-masters dominated slaves
P2: Humans try to instill fear into animals just like slave-masters tried to instill fear into slaves
P3: Animals do fear humans just as slaves feard slave-masters.
C1: The subjugation of animals is much like the subjugation of slaves

P4: Animals are thought to have a lower intelligence than humans just as slaves were thought to have lower intelligence than the slave-masters
P5: People subjugate animals because they think it is normal just as people subjugated slaves because they thought it was normal
P6: Humans continue our subjugation of animals because it is economically benefitial and convenient just as the subjugation of slaves was economically benefitial and convenient
P7: Many humans grow up thinking that animals are here for our use just as many people grew up thinking that slaves were there for a slave-owners' use
P8: When it comes down to it, humans use the bible to justify the subjugation of animals just as slave-owners used the bible to justify their subjugation of slaves
P9: Humans consider their business in the animal industry to be a means of making a living just as people in the slave industry considered it to be a means to make a living
P10: Some humans enjoy being cruel to animals just as some slave-owners enjoyed being cruel to slaves
P11: Many humans consider some animals to be disgusting even though they will eat or wear those same animals just as some slave-owners would consider their slaves to be disgusting even though they would have sex with them or allow them to prepare their food
C2: The conception of animals are much like the conception of slaves

P12: Animals are kept in similar conditions to that which are much like (if not identical to) the slave's conditions
P13: Factory farms keep animals packed together in lousey disgusting conditions just like plantations kept slaves packed together in lousy disgusting conditions
P14: House animals are kept in better conditions but are still held their at the owners discretion and sometimes abused just like some house slaves were kept in better conditions but held at the slave-master's discretion and sometimes abused
P15: Animals are fed lousy food just as slaves were fed lousy food.
P16: Sometimes animals are starved or dehydrated just like some slaves were starved or dehydrated
P17: Animals seldomly recieve vetrinary care because there is simply too many to handle just as slaves seldomly recieved medical care because there was simply too many to handle
C3: The conditions of animals are much like the conditions of slaves

P18: Animals are used to serve humans just as slaves were used to serve slave-masters
P19: Animals are used for profit for humans just as slaves were used as profit for slave-masters
P20: This servitude is against the will of the animal just as the servitude was against the will of the slave
P21: Animals are captured out of their homeland and turned into property just as slaves were captured from the homeland and turned into property
P22: Eventually the captured animals are bred with each other to birth new generations that will support the market just as slaves were eventually bred with each other to birth new generations to support the slave market
P23: Animals are bought and sold on a market just as slaves are bought and sold on a market
C4: The use of animals is much like the use of slaves

P24: When animals revolt they are punished just like slaves were punished when they revolted
P25: Loose (free) animals are taken to the pound or returned to their owners just like loose (free) slaves were taken to jail or returned to their owners
P26: Animals are whipped, prodded, beaten, and branded just like slaves were whipped, prodded, beaten, and branded
P27: When an animal intrudes upon a human's environment the animal is pregudicely executed for their intrusion just as some slaves/blacks were prejudicely executed (hung, shot) for intruding upon white environments
P28: A moral consciousness has began to give rights to animals just as a moral consciousness eventually gave rights to slaves
C5: The treatment of animals is much like the treatment of slaves

Enough points? I left plenty of gaps, I can go on if you'd like. If you are in denial of any of this, then I give up.

Obviously if slaves were considered to be animals, then slaves and animals will be treated the same.

So what the fuck is your point supposed to be? We are way off topic now, but what is your underlying argument exactly? That blacks had it the worst out of all time? Why are you defending that so much? Are you trying to make "your people" out to be the biggest tragedy in history and therefore you need the utmost consideration? Are you playing up the pity card, or the suffering card? Everyone is supposed to bow down to the greatest tragedy of all time and never compare similar tragedies because that would be a disgrace or a travesty? Is it an ego thing? -"That's right, my people have had it the worst, so don't dare compare or challenge." Or do you simply not care to admit that humankind continues to follow its brutal path? I assume it is the former. Please explain to me.


We all know that each of our end is near; the question is do we accept the end of our living existence, or do we accept our existence as dead men...
J-Breakz Date: Saturday, 06/Feb/10, 5:16 AM | Message # 220

Heads
Posts: 2162
Reputation: 0
Offline
hey just for the record, our arguments didn't get heated up to this level ever

livin life like some cheesy movie
eboyd Date: Saturday, 06/Feb/10, 5:27 AM | Message # 221

Heads
Posts: 13145
Reputation: 2
Offline
Quote (J-Breakz)
hey just for the record, our arguments didn't get heated up to this level ever

Lol!


my new theme song



erikboyd60@hotmail.com

"True poetry can communicate before it is understood"

-T.S. Eliot

battle record:

7-0-0

I_Guy Date: Saturday, 06/Feb/10, 6:23 AM | Message # 222

Heads
Posts: 1792
Reputation: 1
Offline
Quote (abanks47)
if humans can stop eating meat why can they not rid themselves of emotion as well? im not saying i dont get sad or depressed but it will not control me and never will affect those around me

You keep on believing that. Once again you oversimplify the human capacity and the nature of human beings. Anyone who thinks they are in complete control of how they feel, they got a lot to learn.

Emotions are irrational psychological responses that originate in the subconscious. They emerge in the conscious when there is an encounter of whatever stimuli or the lack thereof. For the most part, emotions rule people's lives because people cannot become objective to their existence as a human being and the irrational responses human beings have to their existential realm. It is impossible to become objective to ourselve, thus we will always be squirming little subjective beings at the mercy of our emotions. Emotions have an evolutionary explanation, and we are stuck with them. Animals live on emotions, much of which is embodied in "instincts." Emotions are the evolutionary residue of our irrational past. We face rational emergence, but this evolutionary baggage remains with us, and it is useful sometimes, but at other times it can be destructive and tortuous.

Every second of your life is resting upon some sort of emotion. The human psyche rests upon an ocean of irrational chaos. (Ever notice the insanity around you? If you recognize the problems of the world you will see it.) Just take a look at a child and you will see crystal clear irrational chaos. We only learn to suppress those childish tantrums, we never get rid of them.

This inborn insanity, this natural irrationality, this evolved subconscious emotional chaos is all the result of long ago evolving from inorganic non-life elements. We have a long way to go before we become emotionless, rid irrationality, and become substantially rational. But for now, our psychological stability is an ocean of emotion. We try to build our logic and rationality upon the thickening ice that floats atop the waves. We try to find stability where we can. So don't tell me that you can disregard your emotions at "will" if need be. Because they knock everyone off balance, somewhere, at some point.

A lot of people try to fool themselves into thinking that they are "strong" and can control their emotions (as if there is a mind-body dualism and as if they have the free-will to do so). They fail to see that our beingness is an arena of one system. All aspects of of our being coalesce as a single complex chemical in an orgainsm that is the world. They fail to see the fundemental one-ness of our being. So there is no controlling anything. Something cannot control that which makes it what it is. Some deny this, some fail to see this. As a result, they end up becoming very confused and frustrated people. Don't be one of them. They only suppress their emotions, they do not get rid of them. (Not to sound cliche) but I know because I used to be like that. So it's something that I reflect upon deeply.

But anyways, not to rant too much...

Quote (abanks47)
i show emotion when it is beneficial but if it serves no point why do it?
Relieving emotion is needed biologically. It is a healthy process needed to maintain psychological equilibrium. However, it is important to exercise your emotions sincerely. Playing them up or masquerading them is worthless, and harmful. Don't think I don't know the difference. It is a vital difference. But no, there is no need to "dry my eyes," there is no crying going on here. My point was that if emotion comes out sometimes, then it will do so. To expect someone to control it is to expect someone to evaporate the waves beneath their feet. Sure, emotion can be suppressed or apologized for later, but if the emotions emerge (offensively), then whoops. No blame in my perpective. Because I try to understand what it really is to be a human being. And I do not see it as a multiplicity of fallacious dichotomies that misconstrues a human being to be something simplified to fit our ignorantly arrogant flawed historical assumptions of what it is to be human.


We all know that each of our end is near; the question is do we accept the end of our living existence, or do we accept our existence as dead men...
abanks47 Date: Saturday, 06/Feb/10, 2:20 PM | Message # 223

Emcees
Posts: 1466
Reputation: 0
Offline
Quote (eboyd)
Abanks, Stalin's death toll trumps Hitler's by quite a bit. Do we say that "what Hitler did doesn't compare to what Stalin did" and use that statement to justify what Hitler did? No. While the statement is technically true, that still doesn't change that what Hitler did was one of the most terrible atrocities in human history. Genocide is genocide, no matter what the scale or degree. Same goes for the situation you describe. Slavery is slavery, regardless of the scale or degree. This goes for any atrocity (of which what we do to animals covers quite a few).

Here's my question to you as both a meat eater and a fellow human seeking to live by the best morals possible: would you agree that if we could sufficiently replace meat (in price, taste, nutritional value, etc.), being as -- I would assume -- we can both agree that humans are in no way more valuable than animals, that it would be morally correct for us to oblige to discontinue the consumption of meat?


if it were proven to be without a doubt on all those terms you mentioned true than sure why not. i would still be concerned over the lasting affects though. i never said the way animals are treated was not important, but i still feel the enslavement of an entire race of people to be a little more important than the killing of animals for our sustenance. it is not a fucking genocide or a holocaust, im sorry but i do not see it as such. I'm sure there are people who do commit genocide against animals but i do not see the food industry as committing this "atrocity" since the meat is being used

Quote (I_Guy)
WHAT THE FUCK IS PROOF TO YOU??????????? Do you realize that neither of us can PROVE our claim? That's why you are not reasonable and don't understand the foundations of logical arguments. All I can do is provide evidence, and if your dense ass can't put it together then there is nothing I can do about it.

At I_GUY, stop quoting half of what im saying. i didnt ask for proof of salve=animal treatment. if you read the entire statement i said i moved on and went back to the older topic of:
Quote (abanks47)
you said that vegetarians fight is similar to that of slave abolitionists. you have not IN ANY CAPACITY proven that.

the shit your giving me is still no proof of that. how is it that you eating no meat similar to that of someone fighting to get an ENTIRE RACE OF PEOPLE WHOS ORIGINAL SKIN COLOR WAS CLEANSED FROM 100S OF YEARS OF RAPE SIMILAR. YOU SOUND LIKE AN IDIOT FOR EVEN MAKING THAT CLAIM.

Once again, your generalizing the human race as if we all do this. maybe you do these things but i for one do not.

Quote (I_Guy)
P1: Humans dominate other animals just like slave-masters dominated slaves

Agreed

Quote (I_Guy)
P2: Humans try to instill fear into animals just like slave-masters tried to instill fear into slaves

Yeah, i think the fear slave masters instilled was a little different

Quote (I_Guy)
P3: Animals do fear humans just as slaves feard slave-masters.

Human minds are more complex are they not? Do you feel slaves think the same way animals do? no i dont think you do so i feel the fear maybe a tad more intense for the slaves

Quote (I_Guy)
C1: The subjugation of animals is much like the subjugation of slaves

agreed to an extent. once again the keeping of animals for food i dont really see as subjugation. its there for eating

Quote (I_Guy)
P4: Animals are thought to have a lower intelligence than humans just as slaves were thought to have lower intelligence than the slave-masters

i do not feel this. im not saying that a monkey can pass sats but there things that animals do that i respect as intellignece and dont feel them to be stupider than humans.

Quote (I_Guy)
P5: People subjugate animals because they think it is normal just as people subjugated slaves because they thought it was normal

Now your cross referencing old shit? dont double down your "points"

Quote (I_Guy)
P6: Humans continue our subjugation of animals because it is economically benefitial and convenient just as the subjugation of slaves was economically benefitial and convenient

agreed, oh dont forget the point where it helps sustain human life in terms of the "subjugation" of animals

Quote (I_Guy)
P7: Many humans grow up thinking that animals are here for our use just as many people grew up thinking that slaves were there for a slave-owners' use

not true by any means, thats poor parenting if that is the case

Quote (I_Guy)
P8: When it comes down to it, humans use the bible to justify the subjugation of animals just as slave-owners used the bible to justify their subjugation of slaves

where does anyone say, i keep this bull because the bible says it coo?

Quote (I_Guy)
P9: Humans consider their business in the animal industry to be a means of making a living just as people in the slave industry considered it to be a means to make a living

agreed

Quote (I_Guy)
P10: Some humans enjoy being cruel to animals just as some slave-owners enjoyed being cruel to slaves

agreed, i like how you felt the need to say some humans here. do you think all humans are guilty of your other "points"

Quote (I_Guy)
P11: Many humans consider some animals to be disgusting even though they will eat or wear those same animals just as some slave-owners would consider their slaves to be disgusting even though they would have sex with them or allow them to prepare their food

agreed, once again distinguishing between some and all humans

Quote (I_Guy)
C2: The conception of animals are much like the conception of slaves

in your opinion, your a vegetarian

Quote (I_Guy)
P12: Animals are kept in similar conditions to that which are much like (if not identical to) the slave's conditions

in some cases. ive seen a house for someones dogs before. i know my cat is not living in a fucking shack so i can guarantee she is not in slave like conditions

Quote (I_Guy)
P13: Factory farms keep animals packed together in lousey disgusting conditions just like plantations kept slaves packed together in lousy disgusting conditions

hmmm, they didnt pack them as bad as farmers do cattle in present day, but its not as bad as the middle passage. i take that back there are certain areas that are as bad middle passage. a town called calingas i believe on the way to LA has a very large coral packed to the brim with cattle intended for slaughter

Quote (I_Guy)
P14: House animals are kept in better conditions but are still held their at the owners discretion and sometimes abused just like some house slaves were kept in better conditions but held at the slave-master's discretion and sometimes abused

some people allow there animals to come and go as they please, my cat has this luxury but likes being in the slaves quarters more

Quote (I_Guy)
P15: Animals are fed lousy food just as slaves were fed lousy food.

ive seen dogs dine on ribs and steak while i had a McD's bag in hand. ive seen dogs eat the same food im eating. this is not the case for all

Quote (I_Guy)
P16: Sometimes animals are starved or dehydrated just like some slaves were starved or dehydrated

agreed

Quote (I_Guy)
P17: Animals seldomly recieve vetrinary care because there is simply too many to handle just as slaves seldomly recieved medical care because there was simply too many to handle

i thought slaves were of value? they wouldnt get any type of care? agreed when it comes to animals though. many cases there will be 10s of thousands of cattle and it would be cheaper to just let them die rather than cared for. not saying its OK just agreeing with you to an extent

Quote (I_Guy)
C3: The conditions of animals are much like the conditions of slaves

sure what ever you say, your still vegetarian

Quote (I_Guy)
P18: Animals are used to serve humans just as slaves were used to serve slave-masters

LOL, yeah i dress pigeons up in suits and make them serve me dinner. no purposes are entirley different and i feel is much more rare than salves were forced to do

Quote (I_Guy)
P19: Animals are used for profit for humans just as slaves were used as profit for slave-masters

agreed

Quote (I_Guy)
P20: This servitude is against the will of the animal just as the servitude was against the will of the slave

agreed

Quote (I_Guy)
P21: Animals are captured out of their homeland and turned into property just as slaves were captured from the homeland and turned into property

wow, way to compare the two. i agree to an extent

Quote (I_Guy)
P22: Eventually the captured animals are bred with each other to birth new generations that will support the market just as slaves were eventually bred with each other to birth new generations to support the slave market

agreed

Quote (I_Guy)
P23: Animals are bought and sold on a market just as slaves are bought and sold on a market

agreed

Quote (I_Guy)
C4: The use of animals is much like the use of slaves

no

Quote (I_Guy)
P24: When animals revolt they are punished just like slaves were punished when they revolted

accept we eventually won, or did you not read that far ahead?

Quote (I_Guy)
P25: Loose (free) animals are taken to the pound or returned to their owners just like loose (free) slaves were taken to jail or returned to their owners

yes very good, they were

Quote (I_Guy)
P26: Animals are whipped, prodded, beaten, and branded just like slaves were whipped, prodded, beaten, and branded

you left out raped and killed. wait what only black slaves got this? o ok i guess animals and slaves differ on this level

Quote (I_Guy)
P27: When an animal intrudes upon a human's environment the animal is pregudicely executed for their intrusion just as some slaves/blacks were prejudicely executed (hung, shot) for intruding upon white environments

to an extent. we dont go hunting birds and raccoons. if a bear comes down from the mountains and there is room for danger than they tranq it and return it. if it comes back and there is potential for danger than they kill it. its for your protection. and slaves weren't simply murdered for wandering into white neighborhoods. they were murdered for being black. its very likely that someone who was killed in a white neighborhood would be killed in a black neighborhood buy the very same people. whites would cruise the block looking for victims on occasion

Quote (I_Guy)
P28: A moral consciousness has began to give rights to animals just as a moral consciousness eventually gave rights to slaves

yeah, disregard the blacks saying they deserved freedom the 100s of years. disregard the fight they put up. im sure its the moral consciousness of whites that did the trick. very good point. just kidding that was fucking stupid

Quote (I_Guy)
C5: The treatment of animals is much like the treatment of slaves

once again to an extent

Quote (J-Breakz)
hey just for the record, our arguments didn't get heated up to this level ever

aint no one heated

Quote (I_Guy)
You keep on believing that. Once again you oversimplify the human capacity and the nature of human beings. Anyone who thinks they are in complete control of how they feel, they got a lot to learn.

But anyways, not to rant too much...


dont worry i took the rant out. thanks professor for explaining my feelings to me. now i will forget it all by listening to onyx lol. as i say below i am not in complete control but i dont let emotions get the best of me and try not to let them affect my judgment or allow me to act in a crazy manner. i try to think, and apply thought before i respond to someone tlaking shit to me rather than be spontaneous where it can lead into a fight or worse.

Quote (I_Guy)
Relieving emotion is needed biologically. It is a healthy process needed to maintain psychological equilibrium. However, it is important to exercise your emotions sincerely. Playing them up or masquerading them is worthless, and harmful. Don't think I don't know the difference. It is a vital difference. But no, there is no need to "dry my eyes," there is no crying going on here. My point was that if emotion comes out sometimes, then it will do so. To expect someone to control it is to expect someone to evaporate the waves beneath their feet. Sure, emotion can be suppressed or apologized for later, but if the emotions emerge (offensively), then whoops. No blame in my perpective. Because I try to understand what it really is to be a human being. And I do not see it as a multiplicity of fallacious dichotomies that misconstrues a human being to be something simplified to fit our ignorantly arrogant flawed historical assumptions of what it is to be human.

I dont even know how to respond to this. you quoted me and i expected a response to what i said. i show emotion just not like a blossoming little girl. im at work and someone offends me i wont drop to me knees and scream. i man up and am professional and do what the fuck i get paid for. emotions can be controlled agreed never entirely but to a very and completely manageable level.


A WELL DRESSED SKELETON SLOWLY CUTS YOUR THROAT.

"I Have No Fear Whatsoever of Anybody or Anything" -Malcolm X

“those who consider themselves the most adamant adherents of “real” hip-hop can also be the least knowledgeable.” –Adilifu Nama; an excert from his perception of Nas’s “Genesis”

EmSeeD Date: Saturday, 06/Feb/10, 5:18 PM | Message # 224

Heads
Posts: 11464
Reputation: 8
Offline
Quote (abanks47)
in some cases. ive seen a house for someones dogs before. i know my cat is not living in a fucking shack so i can guarantee she is not in slave like conditions

he's probably talking about animals in factories that are bred to be killed and eaten by us, such as Pig Farms, pigs, chickens etc are all kept in awful conditions, tiny cages, they're barely even able to move they're forced to eat shit to make them fat and then killed and eaten by us. that's what he's talking about not your cat. cats are definitely not slaves lol cats are only loyal to their food.


http://chirbit.com/emseed
http://youtube.com/siwooot
EmSeeD Date: Saturday, 06/Feb/10, 5:21 PM | Message # 225

Heads
Posts: 11464
Reputation: 8
Offline
looks like slavery to me



http://chirbit.com/emseed
http://youtube.com/siwooot
Search: